HomeMy WebLinkAbout13 - OB-1 - Harbor Blvd. Median Enhancement Project - 8/1/2017CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
MEETING DATE: AUGUST 1, 2017
ITEM NUMBER: OB -1
SUBJECT: HARBOR BOULEVARD MEDIAN IMPROVEMENT PROJECT
DATE: JULY 24, 2017
FROM: PUBLIC SERVICES DEPARTMENT/TRANSPORTATION SERVICES DIVISION
PRESENTATION BY: RAJA SETHURAMAN, PUBLIC SERVICES DIRECTOR
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: RAJA SETHURAMAN, PUBLIC SERVICES DIRECTOR
- (714) 754-5343
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the conceptual layout of the proposed Harbor Boulevard Median Improvement Project
(Attachment 1); and authorize staff to proceed to final design and advertisement of the project for
construction.
BACKGROUND:
The Harbor Boulevard Median Improvement Project includes implementation of raised
landscaped medians along Harbor Boulevard between Wilson Street and 19' Street. Harbor
Boulevard currently has a wide painted median within the project limits, and installation of raised
medians with landscaping will make this portion of Harbor Boulevard consistent with the
remainder of the street to the north while improving overall traffic operations.
Public Services staff has secured Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) federal grant
funding in the amount of $528,100 toward the design and construction of this project. Of this amount,
$423,100 is available for the construction phase. On October 20, 2015, the City Council awarded
a contract to Civil Source to prepare design plans for median improvements along Harbor
Boulevard between Wilson Street and 19th Street (Attachment 2).
ANALYSIS:
The need for medians on Harbor Boulevard was established based on review of past accident
history as well as review of traffic operations. Following a review of accident patterns over a five-
year period between 2008 and 2013, staff solicited grant funding from the Federal Highway Safety
Improvement Program. A total of 84 mid -block accidents were recorded during this period, with
17 involving bicycles or pedestrians and 26 being severe broadside, head-on, or overturned type
of accidents. Attachment 3 depicts the accident pattern along the corridor. The median project
was developed to address these type of severe accidents.
Prior to developing conceptual plans, the consultant team conducted extensive traffic data
collection, including traffic volume counts at intersections and all project driveways. Several
driveways were subsequently recounted based on information obtained at community workshops.
Two (2) community meetings were held on this project. The first meeting was held at the
Neighborhood Community Center on August 16, 2016. This was attended by over 30 residents
and business owners. A second community meeting was held at City Hall on May 31, 2017. This
was attended by over 25 residents and business owners. A summary of public comments received
at these community meetings and staff responses are included in Attachment 4. In addition, staff
made several changes to median layouts based on input received at these meetings. Staff also
had several meetings with major business owners, including car dealerships and major retail
establishments, and with other interested property owners along the corridor during project
development.
Attachment 1 provides the conceptual median improvement plan. The proposed median layout
plan improves traffic operations by reducing the number of vehicle conflict points while preserving
full or partial access to driveways with significant traffic volumes as well as those with established
needs due to their operations. Based on staff review of traffic volumes, the volume of diverted
cars that will need to make U-turns is very low and could be accommodated at adjacent traffic
signals without any impact to their levels of service. Additionally, the proposed median openings
have been located to provide adequate access for fire and rescue in this section of Harbor
Boulevard. Landscaping of the proposed raised medians, as well as new parkway landscaping
where space is available, is included to improve the overall look and provide consistency with the
portion of Harbor Boulevard north of this project area.
Staff requests City Council's approval of the conceptual layout of the proposed medians on Harbor
Boulevard and authorization for staff to proceed to final design and advertisement of the project
for construction. Staff will request approval of landscape plans from the Parks & Recreation
Commission prior to the final design of plans.
ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED:
One alternative considered is to not approve the conceptual layout of the project. This will result in
cancellation of the project and loss of the awarded grant funding.
FISCAL REVIEW:
Funding for the project is from the Federal Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) in the
amount of $423,100 for the construction phase. Additional funds from other sources, including Gas
Tax, Measure M2 Fairshare, or General Fund will be required to complete the project. The amount
of additional funds required is anticipated to be approximately $500,000.
LEGAL REVIEW:
The City Attorney's review is not required for this item.
CONCLUSION:
The Public Services Department captured grant funding for the Harbor Boulevard Median
Improvement Project to implement new landscaped medians on Harbor Boulevard between Wilson
Street and 19th Street. This project will improve the streetscape and also the traffic operations along
this corridor. The proposed median plans were developed following extensive data collection and
based on input received from two (2) community workshops. Staff requests City Council's approval
of the project and authorization for staff to proceed to final design and the construction phase.
RAJA SETHURAMAN
Public Services Director
Ir
ATTACHMENTS: 1. Conceptual Median Layout Plans
2. Award of Design of Harbor Boulevard Median Project
3. Harbor Boulevard Accident Pattern
4. Public Comments
DISTRIBUTION: City Manager
Assistant City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
v '
r `
�..r' '-r.._...Cl; -..fin .y • E R : � � � !:. -. - .: e:.. `I+RiY.a - .all.► -Yl::.
1#0,r.
.� .y,r R �wN■
. ti fI R
Pie
art
Q n
A _ .
i
� e
{i
Iu
I
CivllSource
k�
I
L
W W
Z J
J 3
x0
U do
Q m
W
W
N
I
•
«" HARBOR BOULEVARD MEDIANIMPROVEMENTS
® GRAPHIC SCALE
w o zo .o °w°B�° wH«e gm«s" o""'� EXHIBIT
FEET
« /za/zan
CITY OF COSTA MESA W"20,1
«Ee)m z , s
_ _ATTACHMENT 2
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT
MEETING DATE: OCTOBER 20, 2015
ITEM NUMBER: CC -6
SUBJECT: PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES FOR THE DESIGN OF THE HARBOR
BOULEVARD IMPROVEMENTS
DATE: OCTOBER 8, 2015
FROM: PUBLIC SERVICES DEPARTMENT - TRANSPORTATION SERVICES DIVISION
PRESENTATION BY: ERNESTO MUNOZ, PUBLIC SERVICES DIRECTOR
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: RAJA SETHURAMAN, TRANSPORTATION SERVICES
MANAGER, (714) 754-5343
RECOMMENDATION:
1) Award a Professional Services Agreement (Attachment 1) for the design of the Harbor
Boulevard Improvements to CivilSource, Inc., 9930 Research Drive, Suite 200, Irvine, CA
92618, in the amount of $139,850.
2) Authorize the Mayor and the City Clerk to execute the Professional Services Agreement.
BACKGROUND:
Harbor Boulevard is a six -lane major arterial with commercial development on both sides of the
street. Harbor Boulevard, within the project limits of Wilson Street and 19th Street, has a wide -
painted median and provides access to major retail centers including several Auto Dealerships.
The City believes that the installation of raised medians with landscaping will improve safety and
enhance the overall image along the Boulevard.
In April 2012, the Public Services Department was successful in capturing a Highway Safety
Improvement Program (HSIP) grant for the engineering design and construction of raised median
and safety improvements along Harbor Boulevard between Wilson Street and 19th Street. The
City Council approved funding for this project through the adoption of the 2014-2015 Capital
Improvement Budget. This contract will evaluate vehicular traffic and pedestrian movements on
Harbor Boulevard within the project limits to develop a median design plan that serves the need
of the adjoining commercial establishments effectively.
ANALYSIS:
On February 11, 2015, the City issued a Request for Proposals (RFP's) to several consulting
firms for civil engineering design services. Eight (8) proposals were received to provide the
intended engineering services. Proposals were reviewed for compliance with the City's RFPs,
and consultants were evaluated based on project understanding, depth of experience, technical
expertise, and associated factors. Based on the proposals, staff selected two (2) consultants for
an oral interview. After careful review of the proposals and responses during the interview
process, staff finds CivilSource, Inc. well qualified to perform the final engineering design services.
The proposal submitted by CivilSource, Inc. and the responses during the interview process
represent a thorough understanding of the project, complies with the project specifications, and
documents technical ability and experience with similar projects.
I
f
In addition to preparation of the necessary studies, and assessing the needs for access to
adjacent businesses along the project limits, staff proposes to conduct extensive outreach with
the property owners and commercial establishments to ensure their feedback is taken in full
consideration.
ALTERNATIVES CONSIDERED:
One alternative would be to perform the design work in-house. However, the scope of work and
demands of the project exceed staff's resources and time.
A second alternative would be not to undertake this project. However, this will result in speeding and
safety issues to remain along this stretch of Harbor Boulevard and will also result in relinquishing the
HSIP Federal grant funds captured for this project.
FISCAL REVIEW:
The Public Services Department has secured HSIP federal grant funding in the amount of $105,000
for the design phase and $423,100 for the construction of raised medians and safety improvements
along Harbor Boulevard between Wilson Street and 191 Street. The grant funds were recognized by
City Council in the Fiscal Year 2014-15 Budget. Capital Improvement funds will be utilized for the
balance of funds necessary for engineering design. Once the design documents and engineering
estimates are completed, staff will request the balance of the construction phase funding through
Fiscal Year 16-17 budget process.
LEGAL REVIEW:
The City Attorney's office has prepared the attached Professional Services Agreement and has
approved the document relative to form.
CONCLUSION:
After careful review of eight (8) proposals submitted for civil engineering design for raised median
improvements along Harbor Boulevard between Wilson Street and 19th Street and the subsequent
interview process, it is recommended that the City Council award the Professional Services
Agreement to CivilSource, Inc.; and authorize the Mayor and the City Clerk to execute the
Professional Services Agreement.
ERNESTO
Public Serti
G� %2►eA I� � i --
RAJA SETHURAMAN
Transportation Services Manager
ATTACHMENT: 1 - Professional Services Agreement
DISTRIBUTION: Chief Executive Officer
Assistant Chief Executive Officer
City Attorney
City Clerk
Staff
File
2
0
Harbor Blvd
(D
NOT TO SCALE
A
U_
• •••U
o • •
IY
O
LL
..
rn
m
T
II
fE
C
N
Co
• OF •
6 -D -A
Legend
•
Broadside
• Vehicle -Ped
•
Head-on
• Overturned
•
Hit Object
Other
•
Rear -end
® Bicycle Involved
Sidewsipe
® Pedestrian Involved
ATTACHMENT 4
Harbor Boulevard Medians
Questions and Answers
Summary of Public comments/questions regarding Harbor Boulevard Median Project:
Accidents:
1. How do the numbers of accidents along 17th street before and after installation of the
medians compare?
A. The goal of the median project on 17th Street was more of a streetscape
beautification project than safety project. The medians are very short and were
built between driveways. That being said, the average number of accidents per
mile on 17th St, 113, was similar to Harbor Blvd's average, 94, over a 5 -year
period and there was only one reported accident on 17th St in the first 12 months
after the median's construction.
2. What is the breakdown in types of accidents among the 84 cited, whether from turning
movement across Harbor, turning into driveways, jay walking, etc.? Where were
accidents located? What type of accidents were there?
A. Based on the accident data collected and used in the 2013 Highway Safety
Improvement Program (HSIP) application, there were 84 total mid -block
accidents reported in the 5 -year period between January 2008 and December
2012; 37 of which were determined to be correctable by the construction of a
raised median. These accidents were fairly evenly distributed throughout the
reach between Wilson St and 19th St with some concentrations near both
Wilson St and Victoria St. 26 accidents involved `broadside', `head-on', or
'overturned' and 17 involved bicycles or pedestrians.
3. How has the accident profile changed over time, if at all? Is this typical due to
factors such as texting or other distracted driving?
A. The cited `Primary Collision Factors' or `accident causes' have remained fairly
consistent over time and the two most cited cause continues to be excessive
speed and failure to yield.
4. Is the data posted on the web?
A. No but you can request the reports.
5. What is length of project area? How does the number of accidents along the Wilson to
19th stretch compare to accidents along a similar stretches of a mile or so over the
same time period for other streets with similar traffic volumes?
A. The current Harbor Blvd project limits from 19th St to Wilson St are slightly less than
1 mile in length (.89 miles). Over a 5 -year period there were 84 reported mid -block
accidents, 29 of which were head-on or broadside types of accidents, in this stretch
of Harbor Blvd without a raised median. For comparison, the portion of Harbor Blvd
north of Wilson St to Mesa Verde Dr, which has a raised median and is also almost
1 mile (.99 miles), had 109 mid -block accidents, with 15 head-on and broadside.
While these two portions of Harbor Blvd have similar lengths, a number of factors
such as traffic volumes, number of driveways, and the presence of medians slightly
differ on Harbor Blvd north of Wilson St versus south of Wilson St. Taking into
account differences in length and traffic volume the average accident rates for these
two areas are very similar, 1.3 vs 1.4 accidents per million vehicle miles for south vs
north, although the serious types of head-on and broadside accidents were
significantly less on that portion of Harbor BI with a raised median.
6. How are left turns more dangerous than U-turns? Still have to negotiate left turns across
three lanes.
A. Wrong -side of road, improper turning, and right-of-way violation types of accidents
accounted for over one third of all accidents on this reach of Harbor Boulevard and
they almost all resulted in "broadside" accidents that are typically severe and result in
injuries. Construction of new raised medians was chosen to mitigate the identified
accidents by physically separating opposing traffic and reducing the number of
vehicle conflict points.
In general, roadway safety is improved by minimizing the number of conflict points at
driveway intersections since more conflicts increase the risk of a crash occurring. Left
turning vehicles must avoid conflicts with on -coming vehicles from two directions
while u -turning vehicles must avoid conflicts with other vehicles from only one
direction. Additionally, a crash due to crossing maneuvers (created by motorists
crossing the roadway or making left turns) can lead to more severe crashes then
merging or diverging conflicts because of the angle and speed differentials between
the vehicles. Federal highway studies show that it is most beneficial from a safety
perspective to prohibit left -turning movements. Research suggests that approximately
72 percent of crashes at a driveway involve a left -turning vehicle. Constructing raised
medians will physically prevent left -turns and significantly reduce vehicle -vehicle
conflicts. Re -directed left -turning traffic will add u -turn traffic to the remaining left turn
lanes but these locations will be signed and more obvious to motorists.
7. What type of bicycle accidents were there?
A. There were 9 accidents involving bicycles and vehicles over a 5 year period.
8. a. Did you go back more than five years for accidents?
8. b. Were there more accidents five years ago? And less in other median areas?
8. c. You should look at 30 years of data.
A. 5 years of accident data for a high volume highway, such as Harbor BI, is sufficient to
determine accident patterns and develop potential mitigation measures.
The number of accidents on any given roadway naturally tends to vary from year to
year based on a wide variety of factors. Accidents on this portion of Harbor BI were
slightly above average in 2008 and slightly below average in 2012.
9. There are no "boards" for accidents.
A. An exhibit showing the accidents along Harbor BI has been prepared.
10. Did you use same formula as 17th St. Medians?
A. 17th St project was primarily a streetscape beautification project rather than a safety
improvement project.
Access:
11. No access for Red -E -Rentals. How do truck with trailers make U-turns?
A. Currently, approximately 6 vehicles make a left -turn into Red -E -Rentals during the
peak hour. In addition to Charle St access, sufficient width at Harbor Blvd. and
Hamilton St, approximately 320 feet from the Red -E -Rental driveway, is available to
re -directed delivery vehicles or passenger vehicles with trailers to make a u -turn.
12. Overlay zone -future high density housing will have no left turn access.
A. The proposed future residential project located at the corner of Harbor BI and
Hamilton St is designed to have access from Hamilton St and no access to Harbor BI
is planned.
13. Have we looked at access to large delivery trucks? Do we anticipate more of these
on Charle as a result of the proposed project? Project would make semi -trucks do U
turns in a narrow part of Harbor Blvd. or drive down Parsons, Charle or college
streets.
A. Left turn access has been maintained to the larger businesses and street width
and pocket length will accommodate U-turns of large delivery trucks, no additional
truck traffic is anticipated on Charle St with this project. Experienced semi -truck
drivers would plan their route to approach their destination with a right turn into the
driveway.
14. How many businesses would lose left turn access?
A. There are a total of 81 driveways of all types on Harbor BI between Wilson St and
19th St, 32 of which currently have restricted left turn access. The initially proposed
medians would have restricted an additional 38 driveways. With the currently
proposed medians an additional 29 low volume driveways would have restricted
access.
15. How many residences, including mobile homes and residences would lose left turn
access? Have all of the residents been contacted? Garrett Furniture access affected;
access to townhomes will be cut off.
A. Some form of access from North and South will remain to all residential
properties, including the Apartments and the Mobile Homes. In addition to
right turns in/right turns out access from Harbor Blvd to the alley serving as
a secondary access to the Vio Apartments near Garrett Furniture, full
access is available from Wilson St. Due to the need to mitigate accidents in
the vicinity of the Mobil Homes entrance north of 19' Street, access at that
location would be restricted to right turns in/out. Secondary alley access to
19'h Street would remain for the mobile homes and businesses. All
businesses and residents within 500 feet of the project were notified of the
project and invited to the community meeting.
16. 1920 Harbor — existing circulation is enter one side and exit the other.
A. Full in and out access will be provided to one driveway serving this center.
17. How will this affect emergency access? In some spots there is alternate access from the
rear, such as Charle Street, but in others, there is no such option. What kind of delays
would be created and with what consequence to those in need of assistance, especially
paramedic assistance? Has CMFD looked at this? How do we handle along Newport
Boulevard?
A. The longest uninterrupted length of proposed median is approximately 400 feet.
Additional delay due to the new medians would be negligible.
18. It was stated at the meeting that all intersections would accommodate the added
volume of U turns necessitated by the islands. Is this based on current conditions or
general plan buildout? 17th St. left turn lanes are not long enough. Lack of left turn
access to a driveway will require doing u -turn at traffic lights. U-turns will increase at
many intersections. A long term solution may be waiting for redevelopment ideas to
come forward for central district. Disrupting the current flow by installing medians will
instead cause a back-up at intersections by drivers waiting to make a U-turn.
A. New left turn pocket lengths were determined based on existing turning traffic
volumes plus re -distributed U-turn volumes.
19. Is there plans to improve the SB left turn at Harbor/19th.?, long wait for green, backs up,
will back up into through lane. It sometimes takes two light cycles to turn left on 19th St.
commonly sit through more than one cycle when waiting to turn left at several affected
intersections in the middle of the day. These include Harbor and Wilson (west to south),
Harbor and Victoria (south to east), and Harbor and Bay (south to east). Does our
model need to be updated or is our signal timing off? There is a gap between reality
and what the model is apparently saying.
A. Based on current traffic volumes and intersection analysis, the intersections on
Harbor are operating at a very good level of service. The majority of the traffic
signals on Harbor are timed to favor through traffic on Harbor, with the exception of
major intersections such as Victoria and Adams. At times, the time provided for left -
turn movements must be compromised to accommodate the high through volumes.
The timing provided for left -turns will be reviewed after completion of construction
and adjusted to ensure efficient operations.
20. Further north on Harbor Blvd. left turns are restricted - what have we learned?
A. Generally, the elimination of left -turn movements reduces risk of collisions, which is
the intent of this project. When medians are designed, traffic patterns are carefully
analyzed considering a number of factors, including actual or planned driveway
volumes, alternative available access, highway classification and volumes, and
number of intersections per mile, in deciding where left -turn access should be
restricted. In some instances, highways are altered from the original design to
change access restrictions, either to prevent or allow left turn access to certain
driveways, based on a variety of reasons such as changing accidents or volumes,
public input or changed land uses.
21. Adams at Mesa Verde Drive East and Piecemakers driveway, motorists tend to opposite
direction to access driveway and get around median.
A. Median design as well as striping and signing will be used to discourage or prevent
unsafe turning movements.
22. Are there tenant lease complications with restricted left turns in project area?
A. While no properties will lose access to Harbor BI, the City has no information
regarding the details of Landlord/Tenant Agreements.
23. If it's a pain to get to a business, it will make a big difference to their livelihood.
A. Sufficient median breaks and intersections are available to allow u -turn access with
minimal delay to those properties without direct left -turn access.
24. Median at Harbor and Bernard area is not going to work.
A. No change is proposed to the median at the Bernard intersection.
25. Don't get rid of Golden Dragon access.
A. The currently proposed median plan allows full access to the Golden Dragon
driveway.
26. Can you install barriers by the Baskin Robbins on Harbor Blvd. so you can get an idea of
what a median will do to the traffic? It will jam up the area. Can you do this before you
decide to install the median? Put barrels out for a week as a trial. What's wrong with
barrels?
A. The projected impacts and changes to travel patterns are sufficiently predictable to
not require a `trial' of the median layouts. Additionally, creating a `temporary' median
barrier would be costly and not provide similar results of a fully landscaped project.
Traffic Counts:
27. Red -E -Rentals traffic volumes - when were counts taken?
A. Traffic counts were conducted at individual driveways along Harbor Blvd. between
19th St and Wilson St. to identify relatively high volume driveway locations and identify
those locations with a high percentage of left turning vehicles. These counts were
conducted on Friday, December 11, 2015, and on Tuesday, September 20, 2016.
Additionally, traffic counts were conducted in October 2015 at various locations on
Harbor Blvd to establish northbound and southbound through traffic volumes.
28. When are peak periods of traffic volumes?
A. The morning peak period for Harbor Blvd traffic is between 8-9am and the afternoon
peak period is 5-6pm.
29. a. Commercial businesses peak between noon and 2 PM. Is there plans to collect more
data and on different days and times? Gathering data on Fridays between 12 pm to 4 pm
is not ideal. I suggest getting more dates, times and holidays.
29. b. How can data for one afternoon on Friday determine impact for next 30 years? Were
the areas that have been rezoned taken into account for this new project? There needs
to be traffic counts every day of the week to justify this project.
29. c. Would like to see traffic data that is done on another day other than Friday. There is a
lot of activity that is occurs during the hours of 6 to 8 a.m. and 4 to 6 p.m. more than a
Friday.
A. While traffic volumes vary from day to day, hour to hour and from season to season
these variances are typically small and predictable. A single day count for a street
such as Harbor Blvd, for which the City has years of comparable data, can yield
acceptable data for design purposes. In this specific instance, Harbor Blvd traffic
counts collected in 2015 in conjunction with a separate signal analysis study
consisted of 7 consecutive days of count data. Driveway count data for this project,
utilizing one day of data, was collected simply to identify higher volume locations and
those locations with relatively large numbers of left -turning traffic.
30. The traffic on 17th St. increased a lot after the year 2000. Won't this project do the
same?
A. Traffic generally has remained the same or grown very slowly on all Costa Mesa
highways including 17th St and on Harbor BI. The total daily traffic on 17th St has
remained virtually the same, near 32,000 vehicles per day, since 2000. A sense of
increased traffic can be attributed to a large number of factors, including an increase
in the amount of traffic during the peak periods potentially due to an improved
economy, upgrades to area business, as well as the City beautification project. As the
area along 17th St improved businesses attracted more people resulting in an
increase in traffic during peak periods.
31. a. What is the prevailing speed in this stretch of Harbor? It seems to slow noticeably in
the area south of Harbor from the stretch north of Harbor.
31. b. What are relative speeds before and after other median projects?
A. The prevailing speeds (expressed as 85th percentile) along Harbor BI vary from 39
mph between Victoria and Bay St in the south to 42 mph between Wilson St and Fair
Dr. in the north. While the northern portion of Harbor Blvd has a raised median and
the southerly portion does not, the number of business and driveways also varies in
these two locations.
Bus Stops:
32. Do bus stops stay the same? Are bus turnouts part of this project? Move bus stop at
Bernard to front of Toyota. We need more bus turnouts on Harbor. There are no turnouts
between Bay and Hamilton.
A. No changes to bus stops or improvements to bus stops are included with this safety
project.
Bicycles:
33. Are bicycle lanes in the future possible? Is there plans for something better other than
landscaping? Adding bike lanes, walkways for pedestrians or a plan that is more focused
on the environment or be more sustainable would be a better option.
A. Harbor Blvd is currently included in the City's draft Bicycle Master Plan and,
approved, future re -development would include appropriate bicycle facilities.
34. Does having the median take away from ever having a bicycle lane? Harbor Blvd. gets
more narrow south of Wilson.
A. There is currently insufficient roadway width to accommodate bicycle lanes along
Harbor Blvd. Since the proposed medians are located within the current area of the
painted medians, the addition of raised medians will not change the overall travel way
width of the road.
Landscaping & Design:
35. Compare project design against learned problem, benefit cost/ratio of cost/traffic
increase.
A. The construction of raised medians along Harbor Blvd will be funded via a
competitively awarded Federal Grant. Construction costs versus the benefit of
reduced accidents was a major part of the selection process.
36. Narrowing the roadway — how does this promote walkability?
A. Additional landscaping, especially in the current parking areas, add shade and tend to
slightly slow traffic due to the appearance of a narrower street adding to the
desirability of walking along Harbor BI.
37. a. Provide canopy trees to provide shade for pedestrians and bus riders. Skinny palm
trees provide very little shade.
37. b. What types of trees will be planted? Do the selected trees have root impact? Are the
tree roots going to affect the median over time? Need landscape on medians to be low
so it does not block business signage.
A. Current conceptual landscape plans identify a variety of trees and shrubs. Final
design plans will include trees that are low maintenance, sustainable, require less
water and are suitable for their specific location. Landscaping, including trees, will be
selected to avoid damage to the roadway. A system will be used that will limit the
growth and direction of their roots. Certain locations may require slender trees, such
as palm trees, due to a narrow planting area or to avoid blocking commercial signage.
38. Will sycamore trees create more trash?
A. Sycamore trees' leaves fall a lot less throughout the year, about once a year, than
typical evergreen trees.
39. Trees are dying all over the City because of drought. Is irrigation in median possible?
Can you use tanker trucks for watering?
A. Irrigation will be included with the project. In those few areas where irrigation is not
available, water trucks will be used until the drought tolerant trees are established.
Community Involvement:
40. a. Have you spoken to small businesses? Need to speak with small business owners.
40. b. Were tenants notified or just owners? Did you notify residents about the meeting and
project? Tenants need to be notified for this type of change, not just the property
owners.
A. The City has contacted and spoken to many affected citizens regarding this median
project. All residents, property owners and business owners within the project area
were mailed an invitation to the public meeting to discuss the median project.
Schedule:
41. What are next steps regarding schedule?
A. Input into the median design will be solicited at an additional public meeting as well
as at an upcoming Parks and Recreation meeting. Based on the input received, the
median design concept will be finalized and construction plans will be prepared.
42. What is drop dead date?
A. The Highway Safety Grant requires that the City apply for Authorization to Construct
by February 2018.
43. Spoke with Grant, is there two-year window for construction? Is there a timeframe to
fund this project?
A. We have a year to submit the application for grant funding for construction.
44. Long time construction will hurt tenant business. Will the work be done from 10 pm to 5
am?
A. Allowable work hours will be specified in the construction contract documents based
on the most recent traffic counts and maintaining an acceptable level of service
during the peak periods.
45. a. Is there another meeting after Park and Rec meeting?
45. b. These projects tend to gain momentum further down the road. Do we need two
meetings? Two meetings are not enough.
A. In addition to the previously held public meeting, the City intends to present the
project and solicit additional input at one more public meeting and at a regularly
scheduled Parks and Rec meeting.