Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11/20/1972 - City CouncilArchie"Mann Vice Mayor Jordan introduced Jean Markwardt. Jean Plaque Markwardt presented a•plaque to Archie Mann com- mending him -for fifteen -years of civic service and for. just being 'a good friend. Mr. Mann thanked the Council and the people of Costa Mesa, commenting on the quality of service and sacrifice of government officials. Park -Land The Clerk'pxesented for second reading and adoption, Dedication Ordinance 72-44, amending Article 1-E Chapter IX of Ordinance 72-44 the Municipal Code regarding park land dedication or in -lieu fees for subdivision. On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Mayor Hammett, Ordinance 72-44, being AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA AMENDING ARTICLE 1-E OF CHAPTER IX OF THE COSTA MESA MUNICIPAL CODE, RELATING TO PLANNING AND ZONING WITH SPECIFIC REFERENCE TO THE PARK AND RECREATIONAL DEDICATION, was adopted by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None i i REGULAR.MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL CITY OF COSTA MESA November 20, 1972 The City Council of the City of Costa Mesa, California, met in regular session at 6:30 p.m., November 20, 1972, at the City Hall, 77 Fair Drive, Costa Mesa. The meeting was called to order,by Vice Mayor Jordan, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance'to the Flag and -Invocation" by Councilman' Wilson. Roll Call Councilmen Present: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Raciti, Wilson Councilmen Absent: None Officials Present: -City Manager, City Attorney, Director of Engineering Services/City Engineer, Director of Planning, City Clerk Minutes The Vice Mayor declared the Minutes of the meeting November"6, 1972 of November 6, 1972, approved as distributed and posted. Eileen P. Phinney Mayor Hammett introduced Mrs. Eileen P. Phinney, City Clerk City -Clerk, c'o'mmended her on her recen t. ce.rtifi- Certified, cation by the International Institute of Municipal Resolution 72-110 Clerks, and thanked her for the manner in which she performs her ._duties. On motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded -by 'Councilmen Jordan, Wilson, Pinkley,"and Rac1 ti, Resolution 72-110, being A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA COMMENDING CITY CLERK, EILEEN P. PHINNEY, ON BEING CERTIFIED BY THE INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF MUNICIPAL CLERKS; COMMENDING HER _ FOR THE HIGH.QUALITY OF KNOWLEDGE, SKILL AND EXPERIENCE TO OBTAIN SAID CERTIFICATION, AND EX- PRESSING APPRECIATION THEREFOR, was adopted by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett; Jordan; Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES'. Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Archie"Mann Vice Mayor Jordan introduced Jean Markwardt. Jean Plaque Markwardt presented a•plaque to Archie Mann com- mending him -for fifteen -years of civic service and for. just being 'a good friend. Mr. Mann thanked the Council and the people of Costa Mesa, commenting on the quality of service and sacrifice of government officials. Park -Land The Clerk'pxesented for second reading and adoption, Dedication Ordinance 72-44, amending Article 1-E Chapter IX of Ordinance 72-44 the Municipal Code regarding park land dedication or in -lieu fees for subdivision. On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Mayor Hammett, Ordinance 72-44, being AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA AMENDING ARTICLE 1-E OF CHAPTER IX OF THE COSTA MESA MUNICIPAL CODE, RELATING TO PLANNING AND ZONING WITH SPECIFIC REFERENCE TO THE PARK AND RECREATIONAL DEDICATION, was adopted by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None i i 17 Park Land The Clerk presented1for second reading and Dedication adoption, Ordinance -72-45, amending Article 2,. Ordinance 72-45 Division XXII.of the.Municipal Code regarding park land dedication or in -lieu fees for resi- dential construction. On motion by Councilman _ Wilson,,seconded by Councilman Pinkley, Ordinance 72-45, being.AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA, CREATING THE CAPITAL OUTLAY PARK AND RECREATION ACCOUNT; MAKING. PROVISIONS FOR ITS APPLICATION, AND -EXCEPTIONS-THEREFROM; DETERMINING MANNER OF CALCULATION FOR LAND OR FEES, AND PLACING LIMITATIONS UPON THE EXPENDITURE OF FUNDS ACCUMULATED UNDER THIS ORDINANCE, was adopted by .the following roll .call vote: AYES:__ Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS: The following items were removed from the Consent Calendar for discussion: Item 10,.Whee1-0-Rania, Charles Wheeler, for vehicle swap meet sales at the Orange County Fairgrounds; Item 13, application for Certificate of ,Public Convenience and Necessity from Wind Ambulance, Incorporated; and Item.23, Bid Item. _ . No. 204,..1973 Truck, Dump. _On motion by. CouncilmanWilson, seconded by Mayor.Hammett, the following Consent Calendar items were:.approved by.the following roll call vote: AYES:... Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti _NOES:,.. Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Greenbelt .. A,Greenbelt,P.rogress Report from Rod Sackett, Progress Report Greenbelt Coordinator, was received and processed. Mosquito Minutes.of the .309th meeting of the Orange County Abatement Mosquito Abatement,District from Jack H.- Kimball, District Manager,-._were,received and processed. Engineer's.No. 143 A Resolution of the -Local Agency Formation Com - Annexation mission authorizing.the Board of Directors of the Costa Mesa..Sanitary, District to annex terri- tory designated:Eng ineer's No. 143, was received and processed. Public Notice of Hearing before the Public Utilities Utilities Commission of the application of the Pacific Commission Telephone.and_Telegraph Company, for authority, to.increase certain. -intrastate rates and charges applicable..to,telephone.services furnished within _the State of. California, was received and processed. East Side A letter.from the -East -Side Property Owner's Property Owner'.s. Association supporting Costa Mesa's request to Association the.California Highway Commission in urging that Route:55 (Newport Freeway) be considered for a higher priority, was received and processed as consideration to request was given at recent,. Highway Commission Meeting. IS Alcoholic Beverage An application for person-to-person transfer of Licenses an on -sale beer license from Helen F. Kreutzkamp Harvey J. Sanchez to Harvey J.' -Sanchez, 2101 Placentia Avenue; parking approved by Planning, was received and processed. Business License An application from 'Estancia High American Field Applications Service doing business as Estancia High School Estancia High Student Tree Lot, 2323 Placentia Avenue, for a School Student Christmas tree'lot on'Estancia High Tennis Courts, Tree Lot on December 7'through'December 24, 1972, was - approved with'fee waived. Newport An application from Newport Christian Center, Christian Dr. George A. World, Pastor, 15th Street and Center Monrovia Avenue; Newport Beach, for a Christmas tree -lot at 2369 Newport Boulevard, on December 1 through December 24, 1972, was approved with fee waived. Newport Harbor An application from Newport Harbor Y Men's Club, Y Men's Club, Incorporated; Bud Overman, Secretary, 114 East Incorporated 23rd Street, for.a Christmas tree lot at 305 East 17th Street, on December 1 through December 25, 1972, was approved with fee waived. Muscular A'Noti:'ce of. Intention to Solicit for Charitable Dystrophy Purposes from Muscular'Dystrophy Association, Association Orange County Chapter, 12917 Fern Street, Suite A, Garden Grove 92641, for door-to-door soli- citation: and canisters, from December 1 through December 31; 1972, was approved with Section 6914J of Municipal ' Code viaived. R-72-25 Rezone Petition R-72-25, John W. McCray and McCray and' Richard D. Esbenshade, as Trustees, 4570 Campus Esbenshade Drive, -Suite 4, Newport Beach, for permission Hearing Set to rezone property located on the west side of College Avenue between Warehouse Road and Dale Way, from Al to Ml, was set for public hearing at 6:30 p.m., December 4, 1972. Refund A request from Anthony Pools, 5871 Firestone Anthony Pools Boulevard, South Gate, for refund of deposit'on Building Permit No. 35651 and Plumbing Permit No. 6197.7, for construction of a swimming pool, was approved in the amount of $40.00 as recom- mended .by the Director of Building Safety -by -the following roll call vote: AYES: 'Councilmen:- Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None J- 1 Refund A request from Mr. Goehring, 1142 Polaris Drive, Mr. Goehring Newport Beach, for refund of deposit on Building Moving Application No..619, for relocation of a storage building, was approved in the amount of $1,500.00 as recommended by the Director of Building Safety by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Refund A request "from Mr. George Hill, City of Costa Mesa, Mr. George Hill Street Department, Post Office Box 1200, Costa C 1 1 Mesa, for refund. of advance rent on City -owned property at 2153 Placentia Avenue, was approved in the amount of $218.00 as recommended by the Director of Engineering Services by the follow- ing roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Right of Way The following'right of way deed was accepted and Deed ordered placed on record with the Orange County Recorder, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None DATE NAME FOR STREET 10-25-72 Carl and Dan'Arthofer Victoria Street Claims. The following claim received by the Clerk was referred to the City Attorney: Dudley Buck Worthy. Administrative A request for Conference.Expense Advance, in the Actions' amount of $400:00, for a Councilman to attend the Conference 49th. -Annual Congress of Cities in Indianapolis, Advance Indiana, -was approved by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOESi 'Councilmen: None ABSENT: -Councilmen: None PADS Personnel A request for authorization to participate in Public Management . Agencies Data Systems Personnel Management System System, Contract contract with Arthur Young and Company was ap- Arthur Young proved and the Director of Finance authorized to -and -Company immediately issue a warrant in the amount of $20,933.00,;<by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen:- Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Notice of The .City Council accepted the improvements, exoner- Completion 'ated the bonds, and"authorized Notice of Completion Median;'.Islands on to be filed for the Planting and Irrigation for Fairview Road Median Islands on'Faiiview Road north of the San Diego Freeway, by Bob's•Landscaping Service, 16761 Construction Way West, Santa Ana, by the following roll call vote: AYES:- Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Notice of The City Council accepted the improvements, exoner- Completion ated the bonds, and authorized Notice of Completion Tract" 7714 to •be..:filed for Tract 7714, ten lots south of East Sewell Bay Street and east of Fullerton Avenue, by Richard A.:Sewell, 434-A East 17th Street; by the following roll call vote: -AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None 20, Suburbia -Park The'City Council -released the fifteen percent Landscaping retention money for Suburbia Park Landscaping Project Project and -authorized the Director of Finance Retention to make payment, by the following roll call vote: Money AYES: 'Councilmen:' Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: Councilmen: None Wheel -O -Rama Item 10 on the Consent -Calendar, an -application Resolution 751 from -Wheel -O -Rama; Charles Wheeler, -802 French Street, Santa Ana, itinerant, for vehicle swap meet sales at the Orange County Fairgrounds No. 21 or Carnival area, one day a month, was pre- sented. Charles Wheeler spoke in support of his application. After discussion, on motion by �. Councilman -Wilson, seconded by Mayor Hammett, Claim and.carried, the application was denied. Fairboard Mayor Hammett stated that.this application could Subcommittee be -discussed by:the.Fairboard Subcommittee during their meetings with the-Fairboard. Wind Ambulance, Item 13 on the -Consent -Calendar, an.application Incorporated for Certificate of Public.Convenience and Neces- sity from Wind Ambulance; Incorporated, George A. Aquino, Manager; 700 -West First Street, Tustin 92680, for one vehicle to transport convalescent patients only, was presented. City Manager stated that setting public hearing was not necessary as a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity was not required. 'On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application for Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity.was declared unnecessary and applicant -is to file.for a business license. Bid Item No. 204 Item 23 on the Consent Calendar, Bid Item No. 204 1973 Dump Truck forgone 19.73 Truck, -Dump, GVW 46,000 pounds, Held Over opened November 10,.1972, was presented. On motion.by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Council- man Pinkley,; and carried, Bid Item No. 204 was held over for further study. Warrant On motion by Councilman'Pinkley, seconded by Resolution.750. Councilman Wilson, Warrant Resolution 75.0., including Payroll 7221, was approved by the following roll call- vote:. AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT:- Councilmen: None Warrant On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Coun- Resolution 751 cilman Wilson,'Warrant Resolution 751 was approved by the following roll call vote: --AYES: Councilmen.: Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: 'Councilmen.: None =ABSENT:: -Councilmen: None ABSTAINING: Councilmen:, Hammett Claim The City Attorney presented a claim from Suzanne Suzanne Krieger Krieger for personal injuries and property damage, and -recommended denial as there was no liability on the part.of the City. On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, and carried, the claim was denied. Claim The City Attorney presented a claim from Nicholas Nicholas. R. R. Camara for false..arrest and imprisonment, and - Camara recoimended denial as there was no liability on the part of the City. On motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by.Councilman Raciti, and carried, the claim was denied. Public Hearing The.Clerk announced'that this was the time and Master Plan of place set for the public hearing on a proposed Parks ordinance revising the Master -Plan of Parks and Ordinance -72-46 reducixig..the-number.of•development zones from First Reading sixteen to six. The affidavit of publication is on.`file-in the Clerk's office. No communications have been received. No one desiring to'speak, the Vice Mayor -closed the public hearing. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Council- man Wilson', Ordinance'72=46,.being AN ORDINANCE OF THE CI.TY.COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA, ACTING AS EX -OFFICIO BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE COSTA MESA PARK AND RECREATION DISTRICT, REVISING THE MASTER PLAN OF -PARKS AND REDUCING THE NUMBER OF DEVELOPMENT ZONES FROM 16 TO 6, AND STATING Refund REASONS THEREFOR, was given first reading -and R=72-08 passed to.second reading by the following roll call Gerwick vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: None ABSENT: -Councilmen: None Bi -Centennial The Mayor presented a list of names for proposed Committee appointment to -the -Bi -Centennial Committee of Costa Mesa under the leadership of Beverly Carey. The Mayor recommended that appointments of the following members be ratified: Roger Phelps, James Yamanaka, -Dr. Robert Moore, Robert Fisher, Mildred Fisher, Gary Colson, Helen Terry, Robert Moody, Edrick Miller, Dom kac-iti, Duane Albers, Beverly Carey, Edward Carey, Tom Baume, John Leonhardt, David Brown;'Gordori Craig. On motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by Councilman Wilson, and carried, the appointments were ratified. Refund The Clerk presented a -request from Mr. Fred H. Gerwick, R=72-08 300 East Coast -Highway, Newport Beach, for refund of Gerwick fee on Rezone Petition R-72-08, for property at 135 Flower Street; On motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, the request for refund of fee for Rezone Petition R-72=08, was approved in the amount of $100:00, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Councilmen: Hammett, Jordan, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen:, Pinkley ABSENT:: Councilmen: None Appeal The -Clerk presented a request to appeal Planning Riviera Sofa Commission denial on November 13, 1972, of a pole Beds sign request. for Riviera Sofa Beds, 3016 Bristol Street, from"J'and B'Sign Company, Incorporated, 7582 Acacia, Garden Grove. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Wilson, and carried, the request to appeal was granted; ABSTAIN: Hammett. Mr. E. Bauer, representing J and B Sign Company, addressed the Council. On motion by.Councilman Pinkley,:seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the• appeal�of Planning Commission denial of a pole sign request for Riviera -Sofa Beds, is to be heard at the Council meeting of December 4, 1972. gip A&f GJ Harold Ely. On motion by,:Councilman Wilson, seconded by Coun- Handwriting cilman Pinkley., and carried, the request for;a,$50.00 Expert monthly rate.in.crease,,.to.taling $250.00 monthly, in Held.Over contract to.expire.-October"1, 1973, from Harold Ely, Handwriting.Expert., was held over. Appeals Ordinance On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Coun- Held Over cilman;Pinkley, and..carried, a proposed ordinance establishing -separate appeal procedures for Plan- ning,Staff,.Planning Commission, and City Council decisions,.was.held over.. Encroachment On motion by Councilman Jordan, seconded by Coun- Permit 70 cilman''Pinkley,, and carried, an application for Phillips Encroachment.Permit 70,,for Sterling Phillips, Withdrawn 2636 Elden Avenue, for:permission to encroach over.a twelve -foot storm drain easement, on property located at .393 Hamilton Street, was- withdrawn.as requested by applicant. ZE-72-93 The -Director of.Planning,presented from the meet - Miller ing.of October'16, 1972,.an application for Zone Held Over Exception ZE=72-93,. William T. Miller; 1633 Cornwall Lane, pe, for permission to construct a two-story.commercial building to meet the %P" on property located at 236 Ogle Street, in a C1 -CP zone. Applicant was present,and addressed the Council. On motion by Co.uncilman,Wilson, seconded by Councilman Jordan, and.carried, the application was referred back to the Planning.Department and possibly the Planning Commission for.further study. ZE-72-96 The Director;of Planning presented an application Ambassador Inns for.Zone Exception ZE-72-96, Ambassador Inns of of America American,,.in care of.,Dale-L. Ingram, Post Office Held Over Box '229,,El,-Monte, for. permission to construct and operate.a two-story_2367unit motel having 226 open par-king.spaces and.40 covered spaces and with 61.units having kitchen facilities, on property _.located at 2277, 2283,-2293 and rear of 2299 Harbor Boulevard;, , in -a. Cl -CP zone. Mr. Dale L. Ingram, applicant's-representa-tive, was present and ad- dressed the Council. Planning Commission recom- mended approval subject.to conditions and deleting Condition,No. 8., Mr. Ingram stated that this property has not been,purchased and deletion of Condition -No. 8 was'required by the present owner -prior to purchase..,. The dedication and improvements of a twenty -foot alley, as required by Condition No.,8, would be an addition to an alley which presently runs from Harbor Boulevard to Canyon Drive. The,City presently has a twelve -foot dedi- cation. Mr. Olson, present owner of the property, objects to the,.possibility of vehicular traffic using:the-alley as ingress and egress across.. -his remaining property._ Council felt that the future possibility -of additional traffic,in this location required further study, regarding traffic signals, right of,way for a future street, and an over-all study.of,the-.area. On.motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Mayor.Hanmett and carried, the appli- cation was.:referred.to staff for additional study. ZE-.72-97 The,Director of,Planning presented an application Hosfiel for. Zone .,Exception; ZE-72-97, Keith W. Hosfiel, 435.Redlands Avenue, Newport Beach, for permission to,construct four units on 11,403.06 square feet of XV land area (one.unit per 2,850 plus square feet) on property,located.at 201 East 16th Street, in an R,2. zone'.. The-applicant,ag reed to all condi- tions. Planning Commission'recommended approval subject to conditions. On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application,was.approved subject, to conditions as -recommended by the Planning Commission. ZE-72798 The Director of Planning presented an application Fainbarg for Z.one_Exception ZE-72-98,,Allan Fainbarg, 789 Held Over South,.Tustin. Avenue,,Orange, for permission to allow reduction in parking -- 113 spaces required, 37 spaces. available, on property located at 365 McCormick., in an .M1 zone. Applicant was not pre- sent. Planning,Commission recommended approval subject to conditions. Director of Planning read two letters, received from Mr. Allan Fainbarg, stating the maximum.number of.employees will be 10 in the office and 15 in the warehouse and that the f_ acility will -be used for storage of merchan- dise for the Wild West Store,.and from Mr. Richard Kenneth Brooks,,.Jr.,'Con'sulting Architect to the Irvine Indus.trial.Complex, approving the proposed on-s-ite parking. and stating that any required changes to the use of the building would also be reflected in the parking requirements. After dis- cussion,.on motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by Councilman Wi1_son;.an4carried, the application was held over for 30 days. ZE-72-101 The Director of.Planning.presented from the meeting Digas- Company of.November 6,,_1972, an -application for Zone Excep= tion ZE-72-101, Digas Company.of Delaware, 215 South La Cienega Boulevard, Beverly Hills, for ..permission.to.change from conventional service station to self-service station by removing one PUMP island and'adding_a„cashier's cage, four dis- pensers and an air.and water service island, on property located at 3066 Bristol Street, in a C1 zone, Mr. Earl Redmon,.22035 Burbank Boulevard, Woodland Hills,, applicant's representative, was present: Planning Commission recommended approval subject.to conditions.. White Front is the present owner of the property. After discussion, on motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded,by Councilman Wilson, and carried, the application was approved subject to conditions. as recommended by the Planning Commission and,amending Condition No. 1 to allow use of a savings account.pass.book in lieu of a cash.deposit. ZE-72-102 The -Director of Planning presented from the meeting Christiansen of November 6, 1972, an.application for Zone Excep- Denied _ tion ZE772-102, Bent.'Christiansen, 283 Rose Lane, for.permission.to construct four units on 11,750 square,feet of land area (one unit per 2,939 square feet) and permission to encroach two feet into required 50 -foot rear yard setback and zero feet on front and side,.yard setbacks with garages, on property located at 2553 Elden Avenue, in an R2 zone. Applicant addressed the Council. Planning Commission recommended approval subject to condi- tions and- amending, Condition No. 4. Director .of. Planning has determined that this property is a 1 legal lot. 'On motion by Councilman Wilson, ZE-72-113 The Director o.f Planning presented an application Schmidt for Zone Exception ZE=72-113; Harry Schmidt, 1801 Antigua Circle, Newport Beach, for permission to allow reduction in parking of 33 spaces (108 spaces required - 75 spaces provided), and to meet "CP" standards, on property located at 350 seconded_by Councilmin'Pinkley, and carried, the application was denied; Councilmen Jordan and Hammett voting no. ZE-72-105 The Director of'Planning presented an application Bogardus 'for.Zone'Exception'ZE-72-105, Jean V. Bogardus, 721 Shalimar, for permission to operate a guest home with a maximum occupancy Iof five persons, on property located at 717 Shalimar Drive, in an R4 zone: `Applicant agreed to all conditions. Plan- ning Commission. recommended approval subject to. cond'it'ions.' On'motiori by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, and carried, Councilman Raciti voting no, the application was approved subject to conditions as recommended by the Planning Commission. ZE-72-106 The Director of Planning presented an application Bogardus for Zone._Exception ZE=72=106, Jean V. Bogardus, 721 Shalimar, for.permissi.on to operate a guest home with a maximum`occupancy of'five persons, on property located at 721 Shalimar Drive, in an R4 zone.' Applicant agreed'to all conditions. Plan- ning Commission recommended approval subject to conditions. .On.motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, and carried, Councilman Raciti voting no, the application was approved subject'to"conditions as recommended by the Planning Commission. ZE-72-111 The Director of Planning,.pr.esented an application Town and for.Zone Exception'ZE-72-111, Town and Country Country Patio -Shops, Incorporated, 1706 Newport Boulevard, - Delayed for permission to display outdoor patio furniture in front of business address; furniture to be displayed -adjacent t'o. building; all furniture to be displayed.on propeity.of above mentioned applicant, on. property located at 1706 Newport Boulevard,'.in a C2 zone. A telephone request for a delay until the.meeting of January 2, 1973, which is to be followed by a letter, has been received from Mr. Bentley, Planning Commission recommended denial. On motion by Councilman Jordan, seconded by Councilman Wilson, and carried, the application was delayed until the Council meeting of January 2, 1973.. ZE-72-112 The Direc`tor'of'Plarining presented an application Ward, et al for Zone Exception ZE-727112, Fred G. Ward, et al, 605_Flintstone Drive; Santa Ana, for permission to build a,professional office building to meet the CP Ordinance standards and -for a reduction in parking'6f_10 spaces (60 required - 50 available), on property located at .702, 7,08 and 714 Randolph Avenue', in, an AP=CP zone. Patricia Stomel, 2108 Vista Laredo,Newp_ort Beach, applicant's repre- sentative, agreed to all conditions. On motion by Councilman Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pihkley, and carried,- the application was approved subject to ,all conditions as recommended by the Planning Commission. ZE-72-113 The Director o.f Planning presented an application Schmidt for Zone Exception ZE=72-113; Harry Schmidt, 1801 Antigua Circle, Newport Beach, for permission to allow reduction in parking of 33 spaces (108 spaces required - 75 spaces provided), and to meet "CP" standards, on property located at 350 1 ZE-72-114 Wilkinson, Miller and Warmington I- Oral Communications I McCormick, in an M1 -CP zone. Jim Moffett, Architect, 2593 Willo Lane,,'applicant's representative, agreed to all conditions. Mayor Hammett requested that Condition No.15 be added, which would require the developer to submit a letter from the Irvine Industrial Complex approving -the -reduction of parking. Planning Commission recommended approval subject to conditions and deleting Condition -No.. 2. After discussion, on motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by Councilman Jordan, to approve the application subject to condi- tions as recommended by the Planning Commission, deleting Condition No. 2 and adding Condition No. 15, failed to carry; Councilmen Raciti, Wilson and Pinkley voting no. The Director of Planning presented an application for Zone-Exception-ZE-72-114; Will Wilkinson, Lois Miller and Jim Warmington,,1860 Port Wheeler, New- port Beach,.for permission to construct a three -unit apartment complex on 8,476 square feet of land area (one unit -per 2,825 square feet) six percent devia- tion.- an encroachment of seven feet into required 25 -foot rear yard setback, on property located at 180 -Cecil Place, in an. R2 zone. Mr. Wilkinson, 1860 Port Wheeler Place, Newport Beach, agreed to all conditions -and stated that a new fence will be built to replace the old.fence and will be constructed of -block wall and redwood. Planning Commission re- commended approval.subj.ect to. -conditions. On motion by.Councilman:.Wilson,.s econded-by.Councilman Pinkley, and.carr-iedz the application was approved subject to conditions as recommended,by the Planning Commission and adding Condition No.,.15, which requires construc- tion -of a-block,wall and,.redwood fence of new materials all around the property. Anthony Dale'Carpen.ter, 2747 Samoa Place, addressed the Council -regarding -.the accomplishments of the Orange Coast Water -Polo Team. They are currently rated:first.in the;State and could become the State Champions,at the tournaments on December 1, 1972. After the State tournaments, the team will partici- pate in the AAU Indoor'Open Water Polo Tournament in.Puerto Rico as the NIMA Pirates. The team has currently raised, $2,500 of the $6,000 required for the,trip.and would appreciate any backing or sug- gestions -the Council could give them. Council suggested that the.Red Coats, associated with the Chamber of Commerce, or publicity through the local newspapers might be of assistance. On motion by Councilman -.Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, Resolution 72 -111, -.being A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE, CITY OF COSTA -MESA COMMENDING THE ORANGE COAST.COLLEGE WATER POLO SQUAD FOR ITS ENVIABLE -RECORD;. URGING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN SUPPORT OF.THE WATER POLO TEAM; AND URGING ATTENDANCE AT ITS PERFORMANCES, was.adopted by the following roll.call vote:. AYES:- Councilmen:, Hammett, Jordan, Pinkley, Wilson, Raciti NOES: Councilmen: - None - . - _ ABSENT : - .Councilmen : . � None Costa Mesa Mr. John J. Scott, 755 West 18th Street, addressed Bicycle Rodeo the Council in behalf of the Costa Mesa -Newport Harbor Leo's Club, requesting -permission to close Park Avenue between Center, Street and 18th Street, , on March`171973, to enale the Club to conduct the Costa Mesa Bicycle Rodeo on Park Avenue. Mayor Hammett and -City Manager felt an alternate location should be chosen that would'be in a less congested area. On motion by Mayor Hammett, seconded by Councilman Wilson, the request to conduct the Costa Mesa Bicycle Rodeo was approved with the location to be approved by the'City Manager. Mayor Hammett suggested Presidio Square adjacent TeWinkle Park because of its relation to residences and low traffic volume. Mr. Joe'D6naldson,'-2782'San Lucas Lane, thanked the Council for his membership on the Crime Prevention Committee. ' Mr. Dan Johnson;'2512 Colby Place, addressed the Council regarding a parking problem caused by tenants of the Mediterranean Apartments, which are located across 'the street from his property.. Mayor Hammett referred his problem to the City Manager for"stud'y. Mr. John"Tyler,� 2905 Royal Palm Drive, addressed the Council protesting the noise caused by compact cars and motorcycles. Vice Mayor Jordan stated that the City of Costa Mesa has a Noise Ordinance for'this purpose but it is very difficult to enforce. Councilman Wilson requested that the City make an endeavor to enforce the Ordinance and penalize these offenders. Mayor Hammett Left Mayor Hammett left the meeting at 9:05 p.m. Mr. Alex'Takacs, 1982 Tustin'Avenue, addressed the Council'protesting the noise caused by the Costa Mesa and Newport Beach helicopters and the Orange County Airport. He requested that the flight pattern be changed so it does not.cross his pro- perty and limit the use of the helicopters to emergency and chase situations only. On motion by Vice Mayor Jordan, seconded by Councilman Wilson,'and carried, the request was referred, through the City Manager; to Police Chief Neth. Councilmanic Councilman Pinkley reported.that the delegation Suggestions from Costa Mesa to the State Highway Commission meeting in Fresno on Wednesday, November 15, 1972, made a successful presentation. Councilman Pinkley read a letter from the Chairman of the State Highway Commission expressing appreciation for the invitation extended the Commission to use Costa Mesa's facilities for one of their meetings. The Commission has scheduled its meetings through June, 1973; however, Costa Mesa will be considered after that time. Councilman Pinkley requested that letters be sent to Assemblyman Badham, City of Newport Beach, and Bill Banning III thanking them for their support at the meeting. Bob Nolan, City Engineer, was the representative from Newport Beach. 1 7 Adjournment The Vice Mayor adjourned the meeting at 9:25 p.m. Mayo of the City of Costa Mesa ATTEST: - City Clerk of the City of sta Mesa