Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04/01/1974 - City Council3Z) Roll Call Minutes March 18, 1974 Ordinances REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL CITY OF COSTA MESA April 1, 1974 The -City -Council of the City.of.Costa Mesa, California, met in regular -session at 6:30 p.m., April 1, 1974, at the City Hall,.77 Fair Drive., Costa Mesa. The -meeting was called to order by the.Mayor, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag and Invocation by the City Clerk. Council Members Present: Council Members Absent:. Officials Present: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti Hertzog Hammett City Manager, City Attorney, Director of Planning, Director of Public Services/City Engineer, City Clerk The Mayor declared the -Minutes of the regular meeting of March 18, 1974, approved as distributed and posted as there were no corrections. On motion by Mayor Wilson, seconded by Councilman Pinkley, and carried, all ordinances will be read by title only. Douglas Oil On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Refund Request. Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett absent, a re- quest for refund of $10,000.00 bond, from Douglas Oil Removed from Company, 3160' -Airway Avenue, Costa Mesa, was removed Agenda from the Agenda.. CONSENT CALENDAR: The following Consent Calendar items were removed from.the Consent Calendar: Item 19a, Coolidge Avenue storm drain and Mendoza Drive storm drain projects; Item 25, a request from the Beautifica- tion Committee regarding..a Billboard Ordinance. On motion. by Councilman.P.inkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, the remaining Consent Calendar items were approved in one motion by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Clean Air A resolution from the City of -Santa Ana,_ unanimously approving the..".orange County Cities' Policy on Clean Air," was received and processed. Assemb.ly:Bill A resolution from the City of.Seal.Beach, opposing 2942 Assembly Bill 2942, which would reduce the County and cities' share...of motor vehicle license fee revenue by five percent, or approximately fifteen million dollars, and same transferred to..certain mountain counties of the state, was received and processed. Reading Folder.. The following Reading Folder items, in Consent Calendar, were received and processed: Mosquito Abatement Orange County Mosquito Abatement District Minutes District Minutes of their 325th meeting of February 21, 1974. 1 1 1 X37 Assessment A resolution from the City of Newport Beach endorsing Treatment the services of the Assessment Treatment Services Services Center of the County of Orange. The City Council Center adopted similar Resolution 74-21 on March 18, 1974. Senate Bill 522 A resolution from the,City..of Seal Beach supporting Senate Bill 522,.and opposing public employer-employee relations legislation.. The City Council adopted similar Resolution 73-102 on September 17, 1973.. Trailer'Coach Communication:from the Controller of the State of Fees California detailing the apportionment of Trailer Coach Fees for the County, cities, and school districts. Public Utilities Notice.-of-Prehearing,.and Notice of Hearing, from the Commission Public Utilities Commission regarding investigation, for the purpose of establishing a list for the fiscal year 1974-75, of existing and proposed crossings at grade of city streets or County roads most urgently in need of separation, or projects effecting the elimina- tion of grade crossings by removal or relocation of streets: or railroad tracks, or existing separations in need of alteration of reconstruction as contem- plated by Section 2402 of the Streets and Highways Code. Alcoholic Beverage Alcoholic Beverage License applications, for which Licenses parking has been approved by Planning from: Joseph W..and Violet D. Deehan,'to Freddie W. Lee, Arthur F. Logan, Richard B. Young, and John A. McCullum, doing business at 727 West 19th Street; Chick -Teri International Incorporated, -doing business as Chick- Teri,.310 East 17th Street; and Newport Harbor Imports End - Company, doing business at 1635 Superior Avenue, Unit Reading Folder 8..:.. . Permit A request from MSI Data Corporation, 340 Fischer Avenue, Costa Mesa,.to parka second.10-foot by 55 -foot .trailer MSI Data for a.temporary office at that address, was approved for Corporation one year. Business A business license.application from Eloy S. Gutierrez, 709 Licenses East Second Street, Santa Ana, for collection of newspapers Gutierrez for recycling, was.approved. Promotional A business license.application from James M. Hambrick, Distributors Promotional.Distributors, 5600 Orangethorpe, No. 406, Hambrick La Palma, for a promotional sale of housewares, March 20 through.22,.1974,.was ratified. City. of Hope A Notice.of Intention..to Solicit for Charitable Purpose from City. of Hope - A National'.Medical Center, 208 West Eighth Street, Los.Angeles, by door-to-door volunteer solicitation during the month of June, 1974, was approved with Section.9-326J.of .the.Municipal.Code waived. Mardan A Notice -of Intention.. to. Solicit for Charitable Purpose Foundation from.Mardan Foundation of Educational Therapy, 695 West 19th Street,. Costa Mesa,. -by auction of donated handmade. items _to the: public, May 4,..1974,.from 10:00 a.m. to.. 4:00 p.m., at that.address:,.was, approved with Section 9-326J. o:f:_the Municipal Code waived. Set for Public The following-items.:were.set for Public Hearing April 15, Hearing 1974, at...6:30 p.m., in..the Go.uncil.Chambers, 77 Fair Drive, Costa Mesa: R-74-07 Rezone Petition'R-74-07, Costa Mesa Planning Commission, Post Office Box 1200, Costa Mesa, for permission to rezone property located on LaPerle Lane and'LaPerle Place, 330=396 East 15th Street, and 1507-1549 Tustin Avenue, from R2 to R1. R-74-13 Rezone Petition R-74-13, Charles E. Amash, 2981 Bristol Amash Street, Costa Mesa, for permission to rezone property located at 2956 Bristol Street, from M1 and R2 to C1 -CP. Refunds A'refund of a $5,000.00 bond, to J. R.i Slaught.Construc•- , tion Company_, 2082 Business Center Drive, Irvine, on Slaught Building Permit 34937, was',' -approved as recommended by Construction the Director of Building Safety, as all work and condi- tions have been completed at 3180 Airway Avenue, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Schafer A refund of a $1,000.-00 bond, to Paul -Schafer, 2827 Serang Place, Costa Mesa, on Building Permit 38072, was approved as recommended by the Director of Building Safety, as conditions have been met at that address, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti., Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Right of Way The following Right of Way Deeds were .accepted .and ordered Deeds placed on record with the Orange County Recorder by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES:- Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett DEED NAME FOR STREET 2185 Nellie Ruth Segerstrom, Fairview Road et al, with Agreement and Declaration of Sub- ordination 2310 Irene Salter Hardage, et al Paularino Avenue 2307 Duncan Electronics, Incor- Fairview Road porated (Quitclaim) 2321 R and F Construction Orange Avenue Company, Incorporated, '(Corporation Grant Deed) 2322 South Coast.Plaza, a Anton Boulevard partnership (Grant Deed) Claims The following claims received by the Clerk were referred to the City Attorney: Roger John Niewiarowski, and Jeffrie Gibson. Street The street improvements on East Newport Freeway Frontage Improvements - Road, from'Baker Street to Paularino Avenue, have been East Newport completed by the Irvine Industrial Complex, 2122 Campus Freeway Frontage Drive, Irvine, to the satisfaction of the Director of Road Public Services. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, the work was accepted and the bonds ordered exonerated by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members.: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Farad Street and The work has been completed by Troy Investment Company, Master Plan Storm 170.3 Westcliff Drive, Newport Beach, to the satisfaction Drain Improvements of the Director of Public.Services for the Farad Street and Master Plan Storm Drain'Improvemen.ts, located at the southwest corner of Pomona Avenue. ;and 17th Street. On. motion.by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, the work was"accepted and the bonds were ordered .exonerated by the following roll call vote: AYES:- Council -Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Right of Way, On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Certification Raciti, a Right of Way Certification in connection with Fairview Road Fairview Road widening from Princeton Street to Baker Widening Street; AHFP Project No. 690, was approved and the Mayor and Clerk authorized to sign on behalf'of the City, by the following roll call -vote: _AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti Hertzog NOES.: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Informal Bid Bids receiv.ed.for_..Informal-Bid..360-018, for the furnishing 360-018 of two automobiles, Honda Civic 1974 Model Hatchback with manual transmission, are on file.in the Purchasing Depart - Awarded ment. On'motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti., the bid was..awarded to American Honda Motor.Company,-Post..Office.Box 50, Gardena, in the amount of $2,070..40 each, being the lowest responsible bid meeting specifications,. by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council -Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT:. Council Members: Hammett Final Map On motion by.Councilman P.inkley-,..seconded by Councilman Tract 82.41-R Raciti, Final Map of Tract 8241-R, Heltzer Enterprises, Heltzer-, 740 North La Brea, Los .Ange.les.,. developer, located at.the Enterprises... northwest -corner of Paularino Avenue and Ludington Street, was.approved; the Council did accept. on behalf of the City, the Offer of.Dedication to the public for street purposes, Paular.ino Avenue -and Ludington Street; did also accept on behalf,of the City, the Offer of Dedication to the public,, the easements for sidewalk purposes; did also accept on behal-f.of the City, the easement.for storm drain purposes, as shown on this map; did.also accept on behalf of the City, the Offer -of Dedication.of..all.vehicular access rights to Paularino Avenue, except the driveway opening shown -thereon; and.did-also. approve subject Tract Map pursuant to.the provisions --of Section 11587(a) of the Subdivision Map Act, by the following.roll call vote: AYES:- Council..Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES.: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett .On.,motion-by.Counctlman Pinkley;.,seconded by -Councilman Raciti,.the Mayor and Clerk..we.re authorized to sign a Subdivision Agreement for improvements in Tract 8241-R, -by the following roll_.call vote: AYES.: Council. Members: Wilson,�Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Change Order No. 1 Remodeling of Fourth and Fifth Floors of City Hall Notice of Completion Remodeling .'of Fourth and Fifth Floors of City Hall On motion by -Councilman Pinkley, seconded -by Councilman Raciti, Change Order No. 1, representing additions to the contract for the Remodeling of'the Fourth and Fifth Floors of'City Hall by Office Construction Com- pany,.was approved in the amount of $3,974.64, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett The work has been completed to -the satisfaction of the City Manager, for Remodeling,of the Fourth and Fifth Floors -of City Hall. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, the work was accepted, the Clerk was authorized to file a Notice of Comple- tion, -and the bonds were ordered exonerated 35 days - after Council acceptance, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: NOES: Council Members: ABSENT: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog None Hammett Bid Item.237 Bid received for.the_furnishing of One -Each Comfort Station is on file in the Clerk's office. On motion by Awarded Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, the bid was awarded to.Super Secur Comfort Stations, 778 Burlway'Road,_ Burlingame, California, in the amount of $5,610.00, being the lowest.responsible bid meeting specifications, by the following roll call vote:. AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Request to Use A request from the Kiwanis Club of Costa Mesa for use of City Park Costa Mesa City Park on May 11;, 1974, from 7:00 a.m. until 12:00 noon, for a pancake breakfast, was approved subject to the condition that the loudspeaker be operated only between the hours of 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Coolidge Avenue _ Item 19a on the Consent Calendar, the award of contract Storm Drain and for the Coolidge Avenue Storm Drain and the Mendoza Drive Mendoza Drive Storm Drain, was presented. On motion by Councilman Storm Drain Raciti,-seconded by Councilman.Pinkley, the contract was awarded to Valverde Construction, Incorporated, 12990 Awarded Branford - Street, Suite.M, Pacoima, in the amount of $286,731.70, and the Mayor and Clerk were authorized to sign the contract, by the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council -Members: Hammett The City Manager indicated that $200,000.00 had been budgeted for these two storm drain projects. He further indicated that $.270,000:00had been budgeted for.the third project on the Capital; Improvement Program, being the 18th Street - Irvine Avenue Storm Drain. The City Manager recommended a budget adjustment be made reducing the 18th Street_ - Irvine Avenue Storm Drain allocation by $96,000.00. Thisamount.would be reallocated as follows: $14,0.00.00 to the Coolidge Avenue Storm Drain Project, and $82,000.00 to the Mendoza Drive Storm Drain Project. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded Budget Adjustment by Councilman Raciti, Budget Adjustment No. 93, in the Nos. 93 and 94 amount of $82,000.00, and Budget Adjustment No. 94, in the amount of $14,000.00, were approved as outlined, by the following roll call vote: 1 1 G Redevelopment On..mo.tion by Mayor Wilson, seconded.by Councilman Raciti.,.... Agency - Hertzog -and carried, Councilman Hammett absent, a vacancy was Appointed declared..on the.Redevelopment Agency. On motion.by Mayor Wilson,.seconded_by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilwoman Hertzog was appointed to fill the vacancy. Vehicle Parking District No. l Street Project Encumbrances. Budget Adjustment No. 113 .The City Manager presented .a resolution of Vehicle Parking District No.-l,.made pursuant.to.Section:31861, Streets and Highways Code, determining that addit-ional-parking .spaces should-be'acquired and improved.by assessment upon the land in the district., and requesting the City Council of the..City of Costa.Mesa to undertake proceedings in connection therewith.. On.motion.by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett -absent, the .request was approved. The City Manager_,.recommended_,app-royal of .the following Street .Project.Appropriations: an encumbrance of $23,850..00 for.median:strip landscapingon Bear Street; an encumbrance-of'.$16,000.00 for. moving 74 trees from the Fkarv3ew Road widening project; and an additional encumbrance of.$.45.,000.00 for median strip landscaping on Fairview.Road. ..The-reappropriations will come from unencumbered funds in the.Bear Street Project. On motion by Councilman.Raciti, seconded by Councilwoman Hertzog, the.three encumb:rances.. Budget Adjustment No. 113, was approved as outlined by the City Manager, by ,.the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: -None ABSENT: Council Members: -Hammett AYES: Council. Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members:.. None, ABSENT: Council Members: None Proposed Elizabeth Cowley, 2965 Maui Place, Costa Mesa, addressed Billboard' the Council on behalf of the.Beautification Committee, Ordinance requesting that a staff study be initiated as a prelimi- nary step in the preparation of a billboard ordinance. On m-otion.by Mayor Wilson, -seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett..absent, this request was referred to the Planning staff.for investigation, and with the.request.that the staff report back to the Council on the feasibility of initiating a study at this time. Warrant On motion by Councilman Pinkley., seconded by Councilman Resolution 823 Raciti, Warrant Resolution 823, including Payroll 7406, was approved by -the following.roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Warrant n On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilwoman Resolution.824 Hertzog, Warrant Resolution 824 was approved by the fol- lowing roll`.call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: None ABSENT: Council Members: Hammett Claims-.Iskra The City Attorney presented. -the claim of Frank.Iskra, and recommended that it be.de'nied as there was no liab.il- Denied i.ty on'the.part.of. the.City. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett -absent, the claim was denied. Redevelopment On..mo.tion by Mayor Wilson, seconded.by Councilman Raciti.,.... Agency - Hertzog -and carried, Councilman Hammett absent, a vacancy was Appointed declared..on the.Redevelopment Agency. On motion.by Mayor Wilson,.seconded_by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilwoman Hertzog was appointed to fill the vacancy. Vehicle Parking District No. l Street Project Encumbrances. Budget Adjustment No. 113 .The City Manager presented .a resolution of Vehicle Parking District No.-l,.made pursuant.to.Section:31861, Streets and Highways Code, determining that addit-ional-parking .spaces should-be'acquired and improved.by assessment upon the land in the district., and requesting the City Council of the..City of Costa.Mesa to undertake proceedings in connection therewith.. On.motion.by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett -absent, the .request was approved. The City Manager_,.recommended_,app-royal of .the following Street .Project.Appropriations: an encumbrance of $23,850..00 for.median:strip landscapingon Bear Street; an encumbrance-of'.$16,000.00 for. moving 74 trees from the Fkarv3ew Road widening project; and an additional encumbrance of.$.45.,000.00 for median strip landscaping on Fairview.Road. ..The-reappropriations will come from unencumbered funds in the.Bear Street Project. On motion by Councilman.Raciti, seconded by Councilwoman Hertzog, the.three encumb:rances.. Budget Adjustment No. 113, was approved as outlined by the City Manager, by ,.the following roll call vote: AYES: Council Members: Wilson, Pinkley, Raciti, Hertzog NOES: Council Members: -None ABSENT: Council Members: -Hammett 1Ic 4-2 Public Hearing The Clerk announced that this was the time and place set Whittier Avenue for the public hearing to consider the preliminary land General Plan use options of the Whittier Avenue General Plan Study. Study The affidavit of publication is on file in the Clerk's office. A letter has been received from Toshio Ikeda in Held Over favor of planned development residential -medium density use for the McKee property, and the balance of the study area for -light industrial use. A communication has been received from Helen H. Wada, 4401 Stinson Drive West, Columbus, Ohio, requesting'that the current zoning of M1 be allowed to remain on her property, identified as Lot 1207, Whittier Avenue. A communication has been received from the Oceanview Park Homeowners Association, indicating a preference for medium to low density resi- dential development for the study area. The Director of Planning outlined the four land use options as presented by the'Planning staff, resulting from their study of. this area. The Planning Commission recommended adoption of Land Use Option No. 4. Vernon Taylor, 1889 Parkview Circle, and'William Clover, Jr., 1041 Parkhill Drive, representing Oceanview Park Homeowners Association, and Dave Salcido, 954 West 17th'Street, spoke in favor of Land Use Option No. 4, which would maintain the majority of the study area for planned development residential - medium density use. Helen Wada, 4401 Stinson Drive West, Columbus, Ohio; Jim Ruble, 1412 Sandcastle Drive, Corona del Mar, Attorney for Mrs. Wada, and Toshio Ikeda, 4116 Melrose Avenue, Los Angeles, spoke in favor of Land Use Option No. 2, which would maintain most of the property in the study area for limited industrial use. Larry Larsen, 11161 Wickford Drive, Santa Ana, who.identified himself as a real estate agent, spoke regarding residential versus industrial land use values and stated, in his opinion, that the' -current market value of this property is greater for industrial use. Mrs.. McKee, 3324,Wyoming Circle, owner of 11 acres in the subject area, requested a medium density use be placed on her property.and was definitely opposed to an R1 use. James Ikeda, 1709 Whittier Avenue, spoke in.favor of the current Ml designation for this property. William K. Davis, 359 San Miguel Drive, Newport Beach, felt the best use for this property at the present time would be industrial.. There being no other speakers, on motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, Councilman Hammett absent, -the public hearing was closed. After discussion, a motion was made by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilwoman Hertzog, to approve Land Use Option No. 2. After further discussion concerning the McKee property for which a request for medium density had been made, Councilman Pinkley revised his motion.to approve Land Use Option No. 2 with an amendment to show the McKee property'as'medium density. The revised motion failed to carry, Mayor Wilson and Councilman Raciti voting no; Councilman Hammett absent. On motion by Councilman Raciti, seconded'by Councilwoman Hertzog, and carried, this item was held over to the meeting of April_ 15, 1974. Public Hearing The Clerk'announced.that this was the time and place ser_ R-74-12 for the .public hearing for Rezone Petition R-74-12, J. Papineau William Papineau, 9221 Albany Circle, Huntington Beach, for permission to.rezone property located at 139 Returned to Rochester Street, from R2 to C2 -CP. The affidavit of Planning publication is on file in the Clerk's office. The Commission applicant was not present. :The City Manager indicated that conflicts exist between'the Redevelopment Plan, General Plan, and the City's zoning ordinance with regard to.this matter, and that no action can be taken until these conflicts are resolved. After discussion, on motion by Councilman Raciti-, seconded by Councilman 1 1 5 443 Pinkley., and carried, Councilman Hammett absent, this fteiii.was returned to the Planning Commission. Community The City'Manager,pr.esented a.request from.the Aviation Airport Committee concerning participation in the Community Council Airport Council, and recommended that the City not participate.in this council. On motion.by Councilman Denied Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the request was denied. ZC-74-3 The Clerk presented Orange County ZC-74-3, Mesa Drive and Mesa -Drive and. Irvine Avenue. The Director of'Planning indicated that a Irvine Avenue petition containing 52 signatures has been received in opposition to -the proposed project for this property. Since this reaction -was not anticipated, and since other problems have surfaced in .connection with the project, a .meeting has been scheduled.in the near future with those concerned in an attempt to..resolve this matter, and to ascertain the desires of the surrounding property owners. On motion by'Mayor Wilson, seconded by Councilwoman 'Hertzog., and carried, Councilman'Pinkley will attend the aforementioned meeting and subsequently instruct the staff in notifying the County of the City's position with respect to the application for a zone change. Marina Report The City Manager presented the Engineering and Economic Feasibility Study of a marina along the east bank of the Santa Ana River,.prepared by Moffatt and Nichol, Engineers, 250 West War-dlow Road, Long Beach. On motion by.Council- man Raciti, seconded by Councilwoman Hertzog, the report was received and the staff authorized to work with Newport Beach in seeking .the various governmental approvals that would be necessary, to implement this project. Request to The Clerk presented a request to.appeal City Council Appeal - ZE-74-13 decision concerning ZE=74-13, Roger MacGregor., from David e MacGregor- Robertson, 24422 Macedo Drive,:Mission Viejo. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and Hearing Set carried, the appeal hearing was set for April 15, 1974, at 6:30 p.m. Proposed -On.motion by Mayor Wilson, seconded by Councilman,Pinkley, Ordinance. and carried, the proposed ordinance establishing parking Parking requirements and development standards for the ML, MG, Requirements MP, and MH zones, was set -for public hearing April 15, Hearing Set. 1974, at 6:30 p.m. Tentative Map The Clerk presented Tentative Map of Tract 8265, Cliff W. Tract 8265 Krueger; Post Office Box 1553, Rancho Santa Fe, for per- mission to create a one -lot subdivision for condominium Krueger purpose, located at 1845 Anaheim.Avenue, David C. Larsen, from the law firm of Rutan and Tucker, representing Mr. Krueger,.was.present and outlined objections to Conditions 3, 5, 8, and 10 of the ten conditions recommended by the Planning Commission. John Mandrell, representing R. M. Galloway and Associates, 129'Cabrillo Street, Costa Mesa, Engineers for the project, spoke in opposition to the parking requirements; the..conditions.concerning in- dividual.metering:for each unit, and the undergrounding of utilities. After considerable discussion, on motion by Councilman Raciti,-seconded by Councilman.Pinkley, and carried, Tentative Map of Tract 8265, was approved subject to the conditions contained in the,Planning Director's letter -of March 25, 1974, with the.modification.of Con- dition 3 to read: Must comply with the requirements of the Costa Mesa County Water District. ZE-74-17 The Director of Planning presented an application for Remsen Zone Exception ZE-74-17, continued from the meeting of March 18, 1974, for Joyce E. Remsen, 250 West Wilson Street, Costa Mesa, for permission to.operate a pre- school for a'minimum of 50 children, with a maximum of 60 children, located at 183 Monte Vista Avenue, in an R2 zone. The Planning`Commission recommended denial. -Communications in opposition to the application have been received from Herbert S. Corff and Vera Abramson, 133 East 21st Street, Costa Mesa; S. Mathson and Mildred Mathson, 2473 Orange Avenue_, Costa Mesa; Mr.. and Mrs: John J. Doody, 2475 Orange Avenue, Costa Mesa; Arthur E. and'Pearl J. Thurston; and Mr. and.Mrs. Dean Gilbert. Communications in favor of the request have been re'c'eived from Mrs. John D. Wilson; Mrs. Gary L. Meyers, 1615 Harrow Place, Newport -Beach; Diane Jones, 407 Cabrillo Street, Costa Mesa; Mrs. Schuyler C. Joyner, 3037 Capri'Lane, Costa Mesa; Gwen Staats, 486 Flower`Street, Costa Mesa; Mrs. Branch P. Kerfoot, 1420 Antigua Way, Newport Beach; Doctor and Mrs. Donald E. Anderson, 5403 Seashore Drive',•Newport Beach; Mrs. Edward E. Johnson, 964 Presidio Drive, Costa Mesa; Mr. Ben E. Fudge, 599 West Hamilton Street, Costa Mesa; M. -,Simpson; Patricia D-. O'Donnell; Barbara F. Marksbury, 2273 Colgate Drive, Costa Mesa;:Mrs. G. Johnson; Lincoln 0. Sheranian, M.D., 11100 Warner Avenue, Suite 318, Fountain Valley; and a petition containing 14 sig- natures. Richard C. Mauldin, representing the applicant spoke in support of'the application. In addition, the following persons spoke in favor of the request: Walter Albers, 174 Monte Vista Avenue, Costa Mesa; Bennett Jackson; Susan Wheeler; 1979 Tustin Avenue, Costa Mesa; Mike Steiner; and Leonard and Virginia -Logsdon, 183 Monte Vista -Avenue, Costa Mesa. The applicant indicated agreement with.all� conditions. On motion by Councilman Pinkley,'seconded by Councilwoman'Hertzog, and carried, the application was approved'subject to conditions. ZE-74-07 The Director of Planning presented'an application for McMahan'.s. Zone Exception ZE-74-07, McMahan's Furniture, 3089 Bristol'Street, Costa Mesa, for permission to exceed sign Denied regulations=of the"Interim Sign -Ordinance by constructing three above•roof signs at that address, in a Cl zone. The Planning Commission recommended denial. No communi- cations have been -received. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application was denied. ZE-74-15 The Director of Planning pr.esented.an application for Routley Zone Exception ZE=74-15, R. W. Routley, 5232 Royale Avenue, Irvine, for permission to construct a commercial building in conjunction with three existing dwelling units in a C2` zone, located at 1962 Newport Boulevard. The -Planning Commission recommended approval subject to conditions. Communications in opposition to the request have been received`Sydney Stiwee, 1965 Fullerton Avenue, Costa Mesa, and•W'3 Martin Fassell,-114 East 20th Street, Costa Mesa. Willard Jordan; representing Mr. Routley, was present and addressed -the -Council in support of the request and outlined the proposed plans for the property. Mr. R. W. Routley''also'spoke in support of his request. W. M. Fassell, an adjacent property owner, spoke in opposition to.the request. After discussion, on motion by'Counci'lman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application was. approved subject to conditions as recommended by the Planning -Commission, and with the added condition that this be subject to the approval and inspection of the Costa Mesa Fire Department. 1 1 1 45 ZE-74-21-R The Director of-Planning,-.presented:an application for Tarnutzer Zone Exception ZE-74-21-R,:Byron,M. Tarnutzer, 2062 Business Center Drive,. Newport. Beach, for permission to construct seven units (one.unit/1,531 square feet) to -meet, CP Standards-in.an R4 -CP zone, located at 148 West Wilson Street. The Planning Commission recom- mended approval subject to conditions. No communications have been received. The applicant was present and agreed _to.all conditions. 'On_.motion by Councilman Raciti, .seconded by'Councilman P.inkley, and carried; the appli- cation..was approved subject -to conditions as recommended by the Planning Commission. ZE-74-29 The Director of Planning presented an application for TylerZone Exception ZE-74-29, Josette B. Tyler, 222 Knox Street,.Costa Mesa, for permission to encroach five feet into the required 25 -foot front yard setback with a patio/wall, at that-.add-ress in an..R2 zone. The Planning Commission recommended approval subject to.conditions. "Communications in favor of the request have been received from D. H. Higgins, 231 Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Dorothy M. Grant, 236. -Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Ina B. Wright, 215 Knox:Street, Costa Mesa; Steve Shutt, 211 Knox Street, Costa Mesa;.Ellen L. Brokaw, 1550 Orange Avenue, Costa Mesa;.Bruce.P. Newbergh, 221 Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Rosa Gonzales,•213 Knox -Street, -Costa Mesa; Helen Kenline, 224'Knox Street, Costa Mesa;.Darien Jones, 240 Knox Street, Costa Mesa;.David I. and Moira M. White, 247 Knox.Street, Costa Mesa; Brian S.. Deton, 213-1/2 Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Mr. Johnson, 244 Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Gloria Patterson, 232.Knox Street, Costa Mesa; Mrs. Poli, 223 Knox Street,.Costa Mesa; Lawrence E. Pease, 243 Knox-Street,.Costa Mesa;. and the occupant of 212 Knox Street, Costa Mesa. The applicant was present and agreed to all.conditions. On motion by Councilman Pinkley,.seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application was approved.subject to conditions as recom- mended by the Planning. Commission. ZE-74-30 The Director of. P.lanning..presen.ted an application for Verrico Zone Exception ZE-74-30, Olindo.Verrico, 1330 Sao Paulo . -Circle, Placentia, for permission to construct a seven - Withdrawn unit apartment complex on--19;,965..square feet of -land - (one unit per 2,852 square feet, five percent density deviation) in an R2 zone, located at 594 Hamilton Street. One communication was.received.from Mrs. Dorothy Doan, 225 North.Star Lane, Newport Beach, in favor of this "request. The Planning Commission -recommended withdrawal as -requested by the.applicant. On motion by Councilman Pinkley, seconded by Councilman Raciti, and carried, the application was -withdrawn. ZE-74-31 The Director.:o.f Planning -.presented an application for Verr-ico Zone Exception ZE-74-31, Olindo Verrico, 1330 Sao Paulo Circle, Placentia~s;=for permission to construct a seven - Withdrawn unit apartment complex -on -20,130 square feet of land (one unit per 2,8_:75 squarefeet, five percent density deviation) in.an R2 zone, located at 2437 Elden Avenue. No communications.have been received. The Planning Com- mission'recommended withdrawal as requested by the applicant.. On motion by Mayor; Wilson, seconded by - Councilwoman Hertzog, and carried, the application was withdrawn. Oral David Burke, 2949 Ellesmere Avenue, Cos,ta Mesa, stated Communications that the_City had removed a tree in front.of his property and was now requesting assistance in having the sidewalk Repair of repaired. Mr.. Burke was asked to discuss this matter Sidewalk with the Director of Public Services immediately following the meeting. Councilmanic Comments . Adjournment Councilman Pinkley.thanked Mr. Joe Donaldson, who was present in the audience,,on behalf of the City for repairing andreplacing the Mesa Del Mar sign. The Mayor declared the meeting.adjourned at 9:15 p.m. For information purposes only, this meeting was,followed by a special meeting of the. Redevelopment Agency. I Mayor of the City of Costa Mesa ATTEST: p6�1 City Clerk of the City of Cost Mesa 1 1 1