HomeMy WebLinkAbout01/15/1996 - City CouncilREGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY OF COSTA MESA
JANUARY 15, 1996
The City Council of the City of Costa Mesa, California, met in
regular session January 15, 1996, at 6:30 p.m., in the Council
Chambers of City Hall, 77 Fair Drive, Costa Mesa. The meeting
was called to order by the Mayor, followed by the Pledge of
Allegiance to the Flag led by Council Member Genis, and invocation
by Father Kenneth Krause, St. Joachim Catholic Church.
ROLL CALL Council Members Present: Mayor Joe Erickson
Mayor Pro Tem Peter Buffa
Council Member Mary Hornbuckle
Council Member Sandra Genis
Council Member Gary Monahan
Council Members Absent: None
Officials Present: City Manager Allan Roeder
City Attorney Thomas Kathe
Deputy City Manager/Development
Services Donald Lamm
Public Services Director William
Morris
Communications Director Vince
Whelan
Transportation Services Manager
Peter Naghavi
Fire Marshal Tom MacDuff
Police Lieutenant Alan Kent
Police Sergeant David Walker
Deputy City Clerk Mary Elliott
MINUTES On motion by Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, seconded by Council Member
January 2, 1996 Monahan, and carried 5-0, the minutes of the regular meeting of
January 2, 1996, were approved.
ORDINANCES AND A motion was made by Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, seconded by Council
RESOLUTIONS Member Genis, and carried 5-0, to read all ordinances and
resolutions by title only.
PRESENTATION Hieu Ho, 3000 Cleveland Avenue, Costa Mesa, representing Costa
Costa Mesa High Mesa High School, reported that the school's water polo champions
School Report and the boys cross-country finalist had been honored at a rally on
January 12; the annual Adopt -a -Family Drive, held during the month
of December, raised $3,000.00 for needy families, the Orangewood
Children's Foundation, the Orange County Rescue Mission, and the
Jason Ferguson Fund; a Red Cross Blood Drive will be held in the
cafeteria on Friday, January 19, from 8:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.;
students and faculty are preparing for final examinations which will
begin at the end of January; the winter dance will be held in
February; International Week, promoting cultural diversity and its
importance in the community, will take place at the end of February;
and the Key Club, with an average of 200 hours of community
service per month, placed first in its division. Responding to a
question from the Mayor, Mr. Ho stated that he had heard the 18 -
acre Costa Mesa High School farm site may be developed into a new
football stadium or a sports facility.
LIS,rw,.r
ORAL COMMUNI- Tony Petros, 2135 Iris Place, Costa Mesa, newly elected President
CATIONS/Chamber of the Costa Mesa Chamber of Commerce, reviewed the focus of the
of Commerce Goals Chamber for 1996: continued effort and support for the City's
young people; resolving conflicts between businesses and community
groups to lessen the need for.new legislation; and investigating the
"return to the source taxation" concept, completing studies on the
issue and involving the City, the County, and the State. He
commented that the infrastructure of the City and services offered
are dependent upon monies which are spent in the City being
returned. Council Member Genis added that monies should be
restored to local government before the State embarks on new
programs with its "excess" funds.
Fairview Park Robert Graham, 3252 Dakota Avenue, Costa Mesa, thought that it
Model Railroad ,would be absurd to relocate the model railroad facility in Fairview
Facility Park and construct a sports complex in the vacated area. Mayor
Erickson replied that'Fairview Park was discussed at the January 8,
11996, Council Study Session, but no formal action was taken.
CONSENT .The following item was removed from the Consent Calendar: Item
CALENDAR 5, Change Order No. 3 to the contract with Brandow & Johnson
,Associates, to administer destructive testing, and to reinstate the
,structural analysis in the "Concept Study" Report, for the Downtown
'Community Center; the seismic retrofit of City Hall, the Police
;facility, and the Corporation Yard.
MOTION On motion by Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, seconded by Council Member
Approved Except ;Hornbuckle, and carried 5-0, the remaining 'Consent Calendar items
Item 5 ;were approved as recommended.
READING FOLDER ;The following Reading Folder items were received and processed:
Claims Claims received by the Deputy City Clerk: James Arthur and
Shirley Jean Schafer; Brad Billington; Salvador Ceja; Richard L.
Clift II; Neal L. Davison; Maureen Gaulrapp; Robert Kelly; Don
' Pokorni; Doreen L. Secor; Carol and Scott Singer; Southern
California Edison Company; and Dennis Christopher Oviatt.
Alcoholic Beverage Alcoholic Beverage License for which parking has been approved
License by the Planning staff: Myo Ja Lee and Hideo Yoshizawa, doing
business ' as Lmari, 375 Bristol Street, Suite A-40.
WARRANTS Warrant Resolution 1615, funding City operating expenses in the
Approved Warrant ;amount of $981,855.73; and Payroll 9526 for $1,385,227.91, were
1615; Payroll 9526 :approved.
REJECTED CLAIMS ;The following claims were rejected:
Ali Ihab Ali and Samir Ali (alleged personal injury, excessive force,
and violation of civil rights).
Jones Julie Anna Jones (vehicle towed and stored).
City of Newport City of Newport Beach (claim for indemnity in fatal traffic
Beach collision).
Southern California i Southern California Edison Company (City contractor damaged
Edison electrical facilities).
1
1
ADMINISTRATIVE An agreement with Kishimoto Architects, 26081 Merit Circle, Suite
ACTIONS/Approved 122, Laguna Hills, for $10,500.00, to retrofit the parking area,
Agreement with sidewalks, building, and toilet facilities at the Costa Mesa Tennis
Kishimoto for Tennis Facility, 880 Junipero Drive, was approved, and the Mayor and
Facility Retrofit Deputy City Clerk were authorized to sign on behalf of the City.
Change Order 3 to
Item 5 on the Consent Calendar was presented: Change Order No.
Brandow & Johnson
3, for $9,000.00, to the contract with Brandow & Johnson
Contract for Down-
Associates, 20301 South West Birch Street, Suite 100, Newport
town Community
Beach, to administer destructive testing, and to reinstate the
Center Testing; Seis-
structural analysis in the "Concept Study" Report for the Downtown
mic Retrofit of City
Community Center;. exterior steel braced frames scheme for the
Hall, Police Facility,
seismic retrofit of City Hall; exterior concrete shear walls scheme
and Corp Yard
for the seismic retrofit of the Police facility; and seismic retrofit of
the Corporation Yard.
The City Manager;: suggested that staff give a presentation on this
item, and referred to the renderings prepared by the consultant
which represent three options to strengthen the buildings to ensure
earthquake safety. He emphasized that the three above-mentioned
facilities house the public safety operations, fire operations, and
basic life support systems. The Public Services Director
summarized the Agenda Report dated January 8, 1996. It had been
Council Member Monahan's understanding that in order to examine
the various options, this item would be considered at the meeting of
February 5, 1996. Because of the potential $2 million cost, he felt
that a public hearing, or notice, or a chance for the public to look
at this and provide input is merited.
MOTION/Approved On motion by Council Member Monahan, seconded by Council
Change Order and Member Genis, and carried 5-0, the following action was taken:
Corp Yard Retrofit; Change Order No. 3 was approved; the seismic retrofit of the
Continued City Hall Corporation Yard was approved; and the seismic retrofit of City
and Police Retrofit to Hall and the Police Facility were continued to the meeting of
February 5, 1996 February 5, 1996.
INTRODUCTION Mayor Erickson introduced, Donna Fagot and Jeannie Corzo,
members of the City Manager's staff.
ADJOURNED TO Mayor Erickson adjourned the regular City Council meeting to a
JOINT COUNCIL/ joint City Council/Redevelopment Agency meeting. Chairperson
AGENCY MEETING Hornbuckle announced that the Mayor would conduct the public
hearing.
ROLL CALL Agency Members Present: . Chairperson Mary Hornbuckle
Vice Chairperson Sandra Genis
Agency Member Peter Buffa
Agency Member Joe Erickson
Agency Member Gary Monahan
PUBLIC HEARING
Rehearing of PA-93-
17/RA-93-02; and
PA-95-40/RA-95-04,
Empire Ballroom
Officials Present: Executive Director Allan Roeder
The Deputy City Clerk announced that this was the time and place
set for the public hearing to consider the following:
Rehearing of Planning Action PA -93-17, Redevelopment Action
RA -93-02, David R. Baade, Attorney for Empire Ballroom, to
consider review/modification/revocation of a minor conditional use
permit, for a 15,000 square -foot nightclub with a dance floor and
billiard tables; and conditional use permits for offset hours of
operation for support office area and valet parking, located at 640
95
West 17th Street in an MG zone. Environmental Determination:
Negative Declaration previously adopted.
Rehearing of Planning Action PA -95-40, Redevelopment. Action
RA -95-04, David R. Baade, Attorney- for Empire, Ballroom,
authorized agent for Atari Corporation/Staples, for a conditional
use permit to allow off-site parking on Thursday, Friday, and
Saturday evenings at Staples, located at 620 West 17th Street in
a C1 zone. Environmental Determination: Exempt.
The Affidavits of Publishing and Mailing are on file in the City
Clerk's office. Communications were received from Mark Korando,
582 Park Drive, Costa Mesa, a record of walk-on patrons at the
Empire Ballroom, from October 5, 1995, through January 4, 1996;
and David R. Baade; attorney for the Empire Ballroom, setting forth
the applicant's current status. The Deputy City Manager/
Development Services summarized the Agenda Report dated January
'4, 1996. The Police Lieutenant provided a brief update on
occurrences at Empire Ballroom which occurred subsequent to his
I report at the meeting, of January 2, 1996, stating that the parking
arrangements have not improved. Due'to several drunk driving and
drunk -in -public disturbances, he deduced that the applicant's
managers are not using good judgment in determining when to stop
serving customers. The Lieutenant reported that he had met with
David Baade to discuss methods of improving the operation.
David R. Baade, 3501 Jamboree Road, Suite 4300, Newport Beach,
explained that due to the status of this matter, the Empire Ballroom
has been unable to implement the Staples parking plan which should
alleviate the walk-on patron problem. He noted that 10 or 11 letters
from neighboring businesses supporting the operation were
previously forwarded to Council, and an additional letter in the same
vein : was received from Trader Joe's, ' 103 East 17th Street. Mr.
Baade proposed quarterly meetings between Empire Ballroom staff
and a Police Department representative. He responded to a question
from Council/Agency Member Hornbuckle by stating that the appli-
cant intends to seek an additional 71 off-site parking spaces for their
staff at Michael's, 610 West 17th Street, and Superior Texaco,
1695 Superior Avenue. Mayor Erickson confirmed for the record
that Mr. Baade had received a copy of the walk-on report.
Mark Korando, 582 Park Drive, Costa Mesa, complained that the
applicant has only delayed the inevitable, and should take responsi-
bility for its impact on the community. He referred to the walk-on
report he generated, commenting that there are persons who will
never use valet parking. He stated that diverting Police personnel
from other areas in the City is a major concern.
1 Susan Gabriel, 197. The Masters Circle, Costa Mesa, one of the
owners of Pacific Mesa Properties, 670 West 17th Street, Costa
Mesa, reported that $5,800.00 had been paid as out-of-pocket
expenses to cover damages since the Empire Ballroom located in this
area; conditions have not improved; and she has had to place boards
over the windows of her business to prevent them from being
broken.
Heather Somers, 427 East 17th Street, Suite 307, Costa Mesa,
I President of the East Side Homeowners Association, thought that
this application would continue to impact the neighborhood even if
additional parking spaces are obtained. She stated that the business
J
F�
97
is located in an inappropriate area, and asked Council to sustain the
previous revocation action.
There being no other speakers, the, Mayor closed the public hearing.
Mayor Pro Tem/Agency Member Buffa asked if the suggestions that
he had made at a previous Redevelopment Agency meeting regarding
signage, left-hand turn prohibitions, and possible measures, had been
accomplished. The Transportation Services Manager responded that
additional City signs had not been installed to date. The Mayor Pro
Tem stated that he had asked that the applicant install signs on the
site, and suggested the installation of at least one City sign regarding
left-hand turn prohibitions. The Deputy City Manager referred to
a letter from the applicant's attorney, David R. Baade, dated January
9, 1996, Page 5, Paragraph 2, reporting that the requirement for the
signage was imposed by the City through the Redevelopment Agency
but was appealed by:Empire Ballroom, and this letter contains their
desire to delete the appeal of this Condition of Approval.
Council Motion to A motion was made by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by
Rescind Resolutions Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, to reconsider the previous decision and
95-97 and 95-98 rescind Resolution 95-97, revoking PA-93-17/RA-93-02, and
Failed to Carry Resolution 95-98, denying PA-95-40/RA-95-04, based on new
evidence.
Mayor Pro Tem Buffa opposed the motion because he felt that the
applicant had not been given the opportunity to implement the off-
site parking agreement and other measures such as signage and
traffic considerations. Council Member Hornbuckle opposed the
motion because the court system encourages applicants being given
the opportunity to correct outstanding problems. Council Member
Genis supported the motion because she thought the applicant has
had the opportunity to correct the -aforementioned problems.
AGENCY MOTION A motion was made by Agency Member Monahan, seconded by
Supported Resolution Agency Vice Chairperson Genis, and carried 3-2, Agency Members
95-97, Revoking PA- Hornbuckle and Buffa voting no, supporting Council Resolution 95-
93-17/RA-93-02; and 97, which revokes Planning Action PA-93-17/Redevelopment Action
Resolution 95-98, RA -93-02, and Council Resolution 95-98, which denies Planning
Denying PA -95-40/ Action PA-95-40/Redevelopment Action RA -95-04, based on the fact
RA -95-04
Council Member Monahan opposed the motion because he felt that
new evidence which indicated that the problem will be rectified had
not been presented. Council Member Genis pointed out that liquor
control and the noise level are to be considered along with the
parking problems. The motion failed to carry 3-2, Council
Members Genis, Erickson, and Monahan voting no.
COUNCIL MOTION
A motion was made by Council Member Monahan, seconded by
Sustained Adoption
Council Member Genis, and carried 3-2, Council Members
of Resolution 95-97,
Hornbuckle and Buffa voting no, to sustain Council's previous
Revoking PA -93-17/
adoption of Resolution 95-97, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY
RA -93-02; and Reso-
COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA, CALIFORNIA,
lution 95-98, Denying
REVOKING PLANNING ACTION PA-93-17/REDEVELOPMENT
PA-95-40/RA-95-04
ACTION RA -93-02, and Resolution 95-98, A RESOLUTION OF
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA,
CALIFORNIA, DENYING PLANNING ACTION PA-95-
40/REDEVELOPMENT ACTION RA -95-04, based on the fact that
no new evidence was presented to alter the fact that the Empire
Ballroom operation is a public nuisance.
Mayor Pro Tem Buffa opposed the motion because he felt that the
applicant had not been given the opportunity to implement the off-
site parking agreement and other measures such as signage and
traffic considerations. Council Member Hornbuckle opposed the
motion because the court system encourages applicants being given
the opportunity to correct outstanding problems. Council Member
Genis supported the motion because she thought the applicant has
had the opportunity to correct the -aforementioned problems.
AGENCY MOTION A motion was made by Agency Member Monahan, seconded by
Supported Resolution Agency Vice Chairperson Genis, and carried 3-2, Agency Members
95-97, Revoking PA- Hornbuckle and Buffa voting no, supporting Council Resolution 95-
93-17/RA-93-02; and 97, which revokes Planning Action PA-93-17/Redevelopment Action
Resolution 95-98, RA -93-02, and Council Resolution 95-98, which denies Planning
Denying PA -95-40/ Action PA-95-40/Redevelopment Action RA -95-04, based on the fact
RA -95-04
•
P
that no new evidence was presented to alter the fact that the Empire
Ballroom operation.is a public nuisance.
COUNCIL MEET- Mayor/Agency Member Erickson adjourned the Joint City
ING RECONVENED Council/Redevelopment Agency meeting, and reconvened the regular
Council meeting.
RECOGNITION Mayor Erickson recognized Ed Decker, Newport -Mesa Unified
School District, and Art Perry, Costa Mesa Sanitary District, who
were in attendance.
ANNOUNCEMENT Mayor Erickson announced that a request had been received from
the Newport -Mesa Unified School District to withdraw Old Business
No. 2, a request to process a General Plan Amendment for the
Monte Vista School site.
PUBLIC HEARING The Deputy City Clerk announced the public hearing, continued
Uniform Building from the meeting of December 18, 1995, regarding the 1994
Code Fees Uniform Administrative Code and 1994 Uniform Building Code
fees. The City Attorney reviewed the Agenda Report dated January
9, 1996, reporting that the fee increase is approximately 40 percent.
There being no speakers, the Mayor closed the public hearing.
MOTION A motion was made by Council Member Genis, seconded by Mayor
Continued to j Pro Tem Buffa, and carried 5-0, to continue this item to the meeting
February 5, 1996 of February 5, 1996, asking staff to provide information on the
actual and associated costs for plan check inspection.
OLD BUSINESS The Deputy City Clerk presented from the meeting of December 4,
School District 1995, a request to process a General Plan Amendment (GPA) from
Request fora Mark Rogers, for Carolyn Stocker, Newport -Mesa Unified School
General Plan Amend- District, to change the land use designation at 390 Monte Vista
ment for the Monte Avenue (6.25 acres at the northwest corner of Irvine and Monte
Vista School Site Vista Avenues) from Public and Semi -Public to Medium Density
Residential. A communication was received from Carolyn Stocker
requesting withdrawal of the GPA request.
MOTION j On motion by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by Mayor Pro
Withdrawn Tem Buffa, and carried 5-0, the item was withdrawn.
The City Attorney announced that the request for closed session
pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8 to discuss possible
purchase of the Monte Vista School was not required.
Council Member Hornbuckle asked the City Manager to solicit input
from surrounding cities regarding their method of dealing with the
increase in Uniform Building Code fees.
OLD BUSINESS
The Deputy City Clerk presented from the meeting of January 2,
R-95-03, City of
-1996, second reading and adoption of Ordinance 96-1, adopting
Costa Mesa
Rezone Petition R-95-03, changing the zoning of certain properties
on East Wilson Street and Santa Isabel Avenue from C1 to PDR -
MD.
MOTION/Adopted j
On motion by Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, seconded by Council Member
Ordinance 96-1
Hornbuckle, and carried 5-0, Ordinance 96-1, AN ORDINANCE
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA,
CALIFORNIA, ADOPTING REZONE PETITION R-95-03,
CHANGING THE ZONING OF 114 AND 118 EAST WILSON
STREET, AND 115, 119, AND 119'/z SANTA ISABEL AVENUE
FROM C1 TO PDR -MD, was given second reading and adopted.
OLD BUSINESS The Deputy City Clerk presented from the meeting of December 4,
School District 1995, a request to process a General Plan Amendment (GPA) from
Request fora Mark Rogers, for Carolyn Stocker, Newport -Mesa Unified School
General Plan Amend- District, to change the land use designation at 390 Monte Vista
ment for the Monte Avenue (6.25 acres at the northwest corner of Irvine and Monte
Vista School Site Vista Avenues) from Public and Semi -Public to Medium Density
Residential. A communication was received from Carolyn Stocker
requesting withdrawal of the GPA request.
MOTION j On motion by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by Mayor Pro
Withdrawn Tem Buffa, and carried 5-0, the item was withdrawn.
The City Attorney announced that the request for closed session
pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8 to discuss possible
purchase of the Monte Vista School was not required.
r . 99
OLD BUSINESS The Deputy City Clerk presented a resolution approving the Joint
800 Megahertz 'Com- Agreement with participating public agencies to establish the 800
munications System Megahertz Countywide Coordinated Communications System; and
Resolution 95-40 concerning the Joint Powers Agreement. The
Communications Director reviewed the Agenda Report dated January
11, 1996.
Ken Bozarth, 243 East 20th Street, Apt. B, Costa Mesa, supported
the new system, and commented that the City should consider
installing low band frequencies for use in the event of a disaster.
MOTION On motion by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by Mayor Pro
Rescinded Resolution Tem Buffa, and carried 5-0, the following action was taken:
95-40 and Joint
Powers Agreement; Resolution 95-40, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Adopted Resolution OF THE CITY OF COSTA MESA, CALIFORNIA,
96-4 APPROVING THE JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT FOR THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE ORANGE COUNTY 800 MEGA-
HERTZ COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS, was rescinded; and
Resolution 96-4, A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF
THE CITY OF COSTA MESA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A
JOINT AGREEMENT TO ESTABLISH THE 800 MEGAHERTZ
COUNTYWIDE COORDINATED COMMUNICATIONS
SYSTEM; AND RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 95-50 AND
THE PREVIOUS JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT, incorporating
the Conditions of Acceptance outlined in the Supplemental Agenda
Report dated January 11, 1996, was adopted.
RECESS
The Mayor declared a recess at 7:50 p.m., and reconvened the
meeting at 8:00 p.m.
NEW BUSINESS
Mayor Erickson presented a request for speed humps on East 19th
East 19th Street
Street. The following communications were received: a petition
Speed Humps
signed by 157 residents, of which almost all live on East 19th Street,
requesting the installation of speed humps on Fast 19th Street
between Fullerton and Irvine Avenues; a petition signed by 48
residents of East 18th Street, Broadway, and Magnolia Street,
opposing the speed humps; letters from 84 residents of East 19th
Street, and two letters from Costa Mesa residents who live
elsewhere in the City, supporting installation of speed humps; letters
from 15 east side residents opposing the project; one letter
suggesting the diversion of traffic from East 19th Street to 17th
Street; one letter supporting the speed humps provided that they are
also installed on Broadway; and one letter suggesting that residents
of Broadway will want speed humps installed to counter any
additional traffic generated by this proposal.
The Public Services Director reviewed the Agenda Report dated
January 8, 1996. The Transportation Services Manager addressed
traffic data, contained in his memorandum dated January 10, 1996,
stating that the traffic pattern on East 19th Street has not increased
significantly in the past 18 years, and a decrease in volume has been
observed since the opening of State Route 55. He reported that a
recent license plate survey had indicated that over 50 percent of the
vehicles using East 19th Street. belong to residents. He listed several
streets in the City which serve to distribute traffic and are
comparable in traffic volume: Del Mar, Orange, and Santa Ana
Avenues, and 22nd Street. The Fire Marshall felt that the
installation of speed humps would be hazardous to fire trucks, and
would delay emergency response time. The Police Sergeant
reported that in 1995, over 300 speeding citations had been issued
on East 19th Street; however, the speeds were all below 40 miles
,per hour. He believed that the installation of the speed humps
,would disperse the traffic to adjacent streets.
;The following Costa Mesa residents commented on 19th Street
traffic problems, the proposed speed humps, and viable alternatives:
Braun Walker, 379 East 19th Street; Ken Bozarth, 243 East 20th
Street, Apt. B; Janice Petrocchi, 180 East 19th Street; Charles
Catanese, 296 East 19th Street; Lefteris Lavrakas, 354 Broadway;
Mike Villani,,200 Flower Street; and Heather Somers, 427 East 17th
Street, Suite 307.
The following Costa Mesa residents spoke in support of the East
,19th Street speed humps: Louis Nigro, 268 East 19th Street; Jeff
McConville, 466 East 19th Street; Marianne Wegener, 251 East 19th
Street; Jim Miller, 245 East 19th Street; Hilario Camacho, 346 East
19th Street; John Daffron, 211 East 19th Street; Cindy Vosseller,
234 East 19th Street, Unit A; David Hartman, 422 East 19th Street;
Bill Borthwick, 2722 San Juan Lane; Christopher Lance, 426 East
19th Street; Mike Brion, 232 East 19th Street; Betty McLean, 389
East 19th Street; Kate Kaylor, 446 East 19th Street; Jon Larson, 174
East 19th Street; Judy Smith, 320 East 19th Street; Mark Abrams,
174 Broadway; Joe Palomba, 476 East 19th Street; Lance
Thompson -Hailstone, 1102 El Camino Drive; Peter Campbell, 215
'East 19th Street; resident at 223 East 19th Street; Bruce MacDonald,
homeless; Wayne Tate, 177 East 19th Street; and Albert Eichler,
406 East 19th Street.
Also speaking in support was Bob Hoffman, 3110 Clay Street,
Newport Beach, a former resident of East 19th Street.
The following Costa Mesa residents were opposed to the 19th Street
speed humps: Dick Hamm, 479 East 18th Street (who submitted the
above referenced petition, opposed to the speed humps, signed by 48
residents); Nancy Nunan, 353 Broadway; Bill Halle, 480 East 18th
Street; Lance Jencks, 443 Flower Street; Jerry Tucker, 466 Flower
Street; Jonathon Perry, 1935 Fullerton Avenue; Heather Armbruster,
216 East 20th Street; Hanna Strever, 230 East 18th Street; Lupe
Cleavinger, 211 Broadway; Jim Palmer, 495 East 18th Street; Cal
Kloeckner, 167 Broadway; Ann Hardy, 188 Flower Street; Justin
Kloeckner, 167 Broadway; Judith Gielow, 469 East 18th Street; Bob
Yoder, 155 Buoy Street; Scott Sneathen, 1965 Fullerton Avenue;
Dana Halle, 480 East 18th Street; Richard Launder, 337 Flower
Street; Greg Wooden, 321 Flower Street; and Bill Nunan, 353
Broadway.
Mayor Erickson expressed an interest in looking into funding for
17th Street improvements; the purchase of an additional radar
wagon; signage on 17th Street; and lowering the speed limit to 15
miles per hour on 19th Street or constructing a barrier at Dover
Street. Mayor Pro Tem Buffa suggested investigating the use of an
automated device called "photocop" which photographs the license
plate of a vehicle which is speeding and automatically issues a
citation. Council Member Monahan suggested initiating an East
Side Study as a Council goal for next year. Council Member Genis
felt that the City of Newport Beach had not been supportive of Costa
Mesa's efforts relating to traffic problems on 19th Street and efforts
to delete the proposed 19th Street bridge from the County's Master
Plan of Arterial Highways. She believed that not only should traffic
on the east side be analyzed but also comprehensive land uses
1
wherein single-family residences are being converted to other uses.
She proposed that the City consider disallowing the replacement of
nonconforming duplexes and triplexes. Council Member Hornbuckle
encouraged pursuing signage in Newport Beach, with the aid of the
California Department of Transportation, directing traffic to the 55
Freeway via 17th Street and to the 73 Freeway via Irvine Avenue;
and reducing_ allowable _truck weight from five to three tons on
residential streets. The Mayor asked the Transportation Services
Manager to review the use of "commercial vehicles" as opposed to
"vehicles" in limiting tonnage.
MOTION On motion by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by Council
Authorized Study of Member Genis, and carried 5-0, staff was authorized to review the
East Side Traffic following concept and make a recommendation at the February 5,
Safety Improvements 1996, meeting: install a speed hump at or near Irvine Avenue at the
Costa Mesa boundary on each of the east/west through streets, East
18th, 19th, 20t4.; 21st, Flower, and Magnolia Streets, and
Broadway; install speed humps at the other end of the same streets,
beginning at the residences; install speed humps on 22nd Street at
Santa Ana Avenue and where the residences begin at the Newport
Boulevard end; install a speed hump on Costa Mesa Street at the
Irvine Avenue end only; and investigate including other streets in the
area in this plan.
Council Member Hornbuckle stated that she would be willing to
delete 22nd Street from the list, if necessary.
Addressing the gentleman who related that he places cones in the
street to enable his children to play basketball, Mayor Pro Tem
Buffa advised him that this idea is unwise for various reasons,
including safety and legal issues. Council Member Genis cautioned
that even with the addition of speed humps, the streets will never be
a safe area for children to play, and encouraged the use of lights and
reflectors on bicycles, wearing light colored clothing towards the
evening hours to ensure visibility, and education in safety measures.
MOTION A motion was made by Council Member Hornbuckle, seconded by
Authorized Develop- Mayor Pro Tem Buffa, and carried 5-0, directing staff to develop,
ment of Residential for consideration at the meeting of February 5, 1996, large -lettered
Signs signs conveying the message, "Slow down, you are entering a
residential neighborhood", picturing children at play, and to
determine the cost of the signs and the method by which to pay for
them, with the intention of immediate implementation.
CITY ATTORNEY'S The City Attorney requested a closed session pursuant to
REPORT/Request Government Code Section 54956.9(a) to discuss the following: City
for Closed Session: of Costa Mesa v. Sid Soffer, Orange County Superior Court Case
City v. Soffer; No. X631808 (Municipal Court Case No. 95C461'T; -and Scarcello
Scarcello v. City v. City of Costa Mesa, Orange County Superior Court Case No. 71-
82-79. The Mayor announced that closed session would be held at
the conclusion of regular business.
COUNCIL Council Member Genis reported that on February 22 and 23, 1996,
COMMENTS at the Biltmore Hotel, the Southern California Association of
SCAG Conference Governments (SCAG) organization is sponsoring a. conference on.
trade between California and northern Mexico. She expressed
73 Freeway concern regarding a Negative Declaration relating to the connecting
Connectors roads to the 73 Freeway, suggesting that the City look into the initial
study and the type of mitigation being proposed to protect the impact
on Costa Mesa streets.
101
10
GMA Funding 'Mayor Erickson reported that he, received a communication
Reallocations regarding Growth Management Area (GMA) funding reallocations
land was asked to return the signed document to the Orange County
;Transit Authority by January, 19, 1996, but preferred that Council
1913 Pomona Avenue ;consider it at the meeting of February 5, 1996, prior to submission.
ABC License Protest ;I3e stated that a letter was received from Alcoholic Beverage Control
'(ABC) regarding protests against issuing a license for the
convenience store at 1913 Pomona Avenue. The City Manager
added that the ABC had taken ' under submission the information
from the City, the Police Department, and neighbors in the area, and
- they are in the process of making a determination which will be
City Manager and announced at a hearing. The Mayor complimented the City
Staff Commendation 'Manager and his staff for the response time to incoming
correspondence, wherein over 90 percent were answered within 10
working days.
ADJOURNMENT TO At 10:35 p.m., the Mayor adjourned the meeting to a closed session
CLOSED SESSION in the first floor conference room to discuss the items previously
announced by the City Attorney.
MEETING iThe Mayor reconvened the meeting at 11:00 p.m., and the action
RECONVENED taken during closed session was announced.
MOTION/City In City of Costa Mesa v. Sid Soffer, Orange County Superior Court
Attorney Authorized Case No. X631808 (Municipal Court Case No. 95C4617), by a vote
to Proceed with of 3-2, Council Members Buffa and Monahan voting no, the City
City v. Soffer Attorney was authorized to proceed as recommended in his
confidential memorandum dated January 9, 1996.
MOTION In Scarcello v. City of Costa Mesa, Orange County Superior Court
Scarcello v. City Case No. 71-82-79, by a vote of 3-2, Council Members Buffa and
Settlement Autho- Monahan voting no, the City Attorney was directed on settlement of
rized the sale of property at 17th Street and Newport Boulevard, as
referenced in his confidential memorandum dated January 10, 1996,
ADJOURNMENT The Mayor declared the meeting adjourned at 11:05 p.m.
r
r of the City of Costa Mesa
ATTEST:
j ..
Deputy City lerk of the City of Costa Mesa
i
1